The Governor apparently gave his State of the State address. I didn’t watch it, but Jen Wagner did: here, here, here, and here. What I take away from her summaries is that the Governor has let it be known that Michigan is an unlivable hell-hole, and, by God, we’re not Michigan.
HB 1428 – Manufacturing Police Insignia
Representatives Tincher and Duncan have introduced HB 1428 which criminalizes the manufacture of a replica of an official badge used by a law enforcement agency of the state or political subdivision. It’s a Class D felony with potential enhancements if the manufacturer knows the badge will be used to commit certain crimes (impersonation of a public servant raises it to a Class C felony and terrorism raises it to a Class B felony.)
It’s a defense that the replicas are too big or too small (less than 50% or more than 150%) to be confused with a regulation badge.
HB 1423 – Satellite Voting
Rep. Vernon Smith introduced HB 1423 which would appear to legislate what ended up happening anyway in Lake County in the 2008 election.
The Democrats, over the objection of the Lake County Republicans, opened satellite voting offices in the cities of Gary, East Chicago, and Hammond. This effectively allowed citizens of Lake County to vote in those three other cities in the same way they could have if they had traveled to the clerk’s office in Crown Point.
SB 379 – Voluntary Restructuring of County Executive and Fiscal Bodies
SB 379, introduced by Senator Boots, provides for a county to elect to transform its governing structure. To do this, the Board of County Commissioners must adopt an ordinance calling for the reorganization of county government such that a unitary executive will replace the three member board of commissioners and assume all of the executive powers of the county. In turn, the fiscal body will become the legislative body and assume all of the legislative authority previously exercised by the board of commissioners.
To become effective, the proposed reorganization must be approved by the voters at an election in an even-numbered year. If approved, two years later, the voters would vote on the first single-member executive.
SB 232 – Public Access
Senator Gard is attempting to stiffen the public access laws with SB 232, primarily through the assessment of civil penalties of up to $1,000 for violations of the public access laws and through mandating that judges and the public access counselor review withheld or redacted records.
There is a section in here that highlights nicely the bind public officials are in with respect to public records.
Sec. 9.5. (a) In addition to any other civil or criminal penalty imposed, if an officer or employee of a public agency knowingly or intentionally:
(1) denies or interferes with a person’s request for inspection or copying of a public record if:
(A) the person’s request meets the requirements of this chapter; and
(B) the record is subject to disclosure by law;
(2) charges a copying fee that exceeds the amount permitted by this chapter; or
(3) discloses without authorization or fails to protect information classified as confidential by state statute;
a court may impose a civil penalty under subsection (b).
Got that? A public official faces a fine if he or she improperly denies a public records request but also faces a fine if he or she improperly discloses a confidential record. It is not always crystal clear which category a document falls under. And if a citizen makes a kitchen sink document request, asking for piles of documents, detecting the confidential record is going to be like detecting the needle in the haystack.
Another wrinkle is that if records are redacted, a judge is required to review public records “in camera” (usually, in his chambers, outside of the presence of the parties) if the records are redacted and a complaint is filed alleging that the records were redacted improperly. I am sure judges will appreciate mountains of paperwork to sift through, comparing the originals to the redacted versions to determine the propriety of the redaction.
Similarly, when a formal complaint is filed with the public access counselor, the public agency would be charged with turning the records over to the public access counselor for review to determine if the records were properly redacted or withheld. Along with the records, the public agency is charged with providing an inspection index that:
(i) gives the title or name of each document, or any part of the document, claimed to be exempt from disclosure;
(ii) provides a description of each document that is general enough to explain the exemptions without compromising the alleged reason for the exemption from disclosure;
(iii) lists the reasons that each document, or any part of the document, is alleged to be exempt from disclosure; and
(iv) fully explains why the alleged reason for exemption from disclosure applies to each document.
I am all for public access by citizens. It is an important part of democracy, but here is the problem. It is dead simple to write a public records request that calls for the disclosure of 15,000 pages of documents or more; requiring no real effort on the part of a citizen who maybe has an axe to grind with the public agency. In response, the public agency has to devote a non-trivial level of resources to finding the documents, sorting through them to determine which ones are required to be withheld, which ones are permitted to be withheld, and which ones are required to be disclosed. Now, the hypothetical axe grinding citizen is not going to be satisfied with any level of disclosure; so he or she spends an hour or two writing a formal complaint to the public access counselor. Now, the public agency is required to go through the thousands of pages of documents and create a privilege index for them. Next up, the aggrieved citizen cuts and pastes his or her complaint to the public access counselor and turns it into a complaint with the court.
Maybe it is just the nature of the beast. Democracy is wasteful and expensive at times. But it seems that, if we are devoted to the idea of streamlining local government and slashing budgets; perhaps a better mechanism is in order to preserve transparency while restraining the ability of a handful of disgruntled citizens to tie up significant taxpayer resources and increase burdens on local government.
I don’t suppose the State wants to fund a public access coordinator for each unit of government whose job it is to track down all the requested documents, redact it appropriately, and do all the indexing when the time comes? Didn’t think so.
SB 222 – Killing Domestic Animals
SB 222 introduced by Senator Arnold makes it a Class D felony to kill a domestic owner animal without the consent of the owner, raised to a Class C felony under certain circumstances, such as if the animal is killed on the property of its owner.
Seems like there should be an exception if the animal is threatening you or your property in some way. Lets say someone’s dog is loose (again) and is now in your sheep pen. That is a problem you should be able to deal with without becoming a felon.
I say this as a devoted dog owner, incidentally. People should not kill animals gratuitously, and they should face penalties if they do. But, at the same time, dog owners (and other owners of domestic animals) bear some responsibility for keeping their animals supervised and under control.
Update My attention was directed to IC 35-46-3-5 which provides an exemption for, among other things, destruction of an animal that is endangering, harassing, or threatening livestock or a domestic animal; or destroying or damaging a person’s property.
Update 2 My attention has also been directed to some background on the proposed legislation.
Two rural Westville men have been arrested for shooting the Satoski family’s beloved 5-year-old Belgian draft horse, Ben.
The horse was shot between the eyes Nov. 16 outside their home at 3810 S. County Road 650 West.
. . .
Cicero, citing the probable cause affidavit, said Waldo and Skomac didn’t know the Satoski family and that shooting the horse was a spur of the moment decision after attempting to illegally poach deer that night. He said the men have confessed to the crime.
. . .
Boyd said the two men are charged with criminal mischief because there is no animal cruelty code in Indiana that fits the case. He said that, unfortunately, Ben is treated like property.
Enshrining Bigotry into the Constitution
According to the Indianapolis Star, the wingnuts are making another run at the Constitution with respect to gay marriage. Reps Eric Turner and David Cheatham are introducing legislation to put a gay marriage ban into the Indiana Constitution. Such an effort was defeated in 2007 and 2008, but apparently extremism in defense of bigotry is no vice. So, they will try again.
The single best thing about that article was that the Indianapolis Star put “pro-family” in scare quotes.
In one sense, I guess, this ongoing discussion about gay marriage has been productive. When I first began considering it, I was luke warm in favor of civil unions, but mostly apathetic to the whole cause. Now, I am to the point where I suspect that depriving gay couples of the right to marry will some day be viewed in the same light as forcing black people to drink out of separate water fountains.
So, now, I’ll go one step further. Not only should the legislature refrain from enshrining such bigotry into the Constitution. They should go ahead and repeal the “defense” of marriage act. It defends nothing. The health of my marriage is not affected one whit if my gay neighbors get married. And history will view us more favorably the sooner we stop treating gays as second class citizens.
Dungy Stepping Down After Seven Years
Tony Dungy will be stepping down as head coach of the Indianapolis Colts after seven years, seven trips to the playoffs, and ninety-two victories, including one Super Bowl win. He will be replaced by Colts’ associate head coach, Jim Caldwell.
Thanks, Coach Dungy, for all the wins and an organization of which Hoosiers can all be proud.
SB 261 – Jail Costs
Senator Kruse has introduced SB 261 which would require costs of incarceration at county jails to be assessed against convicts who are imprisoned at the jails. Currently it’s optional with the counties as to whether they would like to adopt an ordinance providing for the collection of jail costs. (The fiscal impact statement (pdf) provides a nice explanation of how the bill changes the status quo.)
I have mixed feelings on this one. Theoretically, making wrongdoers pay for the cost of their wrongdoing, including costs of incarceration, is a good thing. But imposing another financial burden on folks who are already on the edge might push them over. Collection is another issue. Currently in Tippecanoe County, we are pursuing a huge number of unpaid Community Corrections fees (fees for being on probation, house arrest, etc.) You collect what you can, but often the money simply isn’t there. And while, technically it might be an option under their sentence, the reality is that throwing them back in jail for non-payment is rarely a cost-effective solution.
Reduction of Attorney’s Fees on Recovery of Medicaid Liens
Under SB 85, Medicaid liens would not get recovered or Medicaid would not pay its fair share in the cost of recovery.
Currently, if a person covered by Medicaid is injured by a third party, the person’s medical bills are paid by Medicaid and Medicaid has a lien against any recovery made against the third party. Typically, such a case would be taken on a contingency fee basis by a personal injury attorney. (Medicaid recipients almost by definition would not have money to pay an hourly fee to an attorney.) A typical contingency fee is 1/3 of the recovery. That may seem steep until one considers that, if the case is unsuccessful, the attorney gets nothing — has worked for free. In effect, the successful cases subsidize the unsuccessful ones.
If the case against the third party is successful, typically money has to go toward satisfying the Medicaid lien before any money goes to the injured party. (There is a lien reduction statute that applies to regular insurance payments in some circumstances, I am not certain off hand of its applicability to Medicaid payments.) Medicaid has received a benefit from the attorney’s work, it is only fair that Medicaid pay its fair share of the attorney’s fees. Under current law, Medicaid is required to pay an attorney’s fee of 25% of the recovery prior to suit and 1/3 after suit is filed. SB 85 proposes to limit those amounts to 7.5% and 10% respectively.
So, let’s say you have a typical 1/3 contingency fee case. The injured party has $50,000 in medical bills paid by Medicaid and the third party has $100,000 auto insurance and not much in the way of assets beyond that. There is a $100,000 recovery after suit is filed. The total attorney’s fee is $33,333. Medicaid has recovered $50,000 and, therefore, pays $5,000 of the attorney’s fee. That leaves the injured party to pay the remaining $28,333. The injured party has paid 5 times the legal fees for the same gross $50,000 recovery and nets $21,667 to compensate him or her for lost wages, pain and suffering, and future out of pocket medical expenses.
I don’t do much in the way of personal injury work, but this still seems like a bad bill to me.
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 305
- 306
- 307
- 308
- 309
- …
- 690
- Next Page »