Norm Cox has an entry entitled “Battle Lines,” describing the past week in state government. Gov. Daniels treated us to some tough talk and some trashing on neighboring states, but not much talk about jobs. He said that these tough economic conditions were the time to separate the “winners from the whiners.” The Democrats hit back bringing a parade of Indiana workers who couldn’t get any satisfaction from the Governor’s Department of Workforce Development which has seemingly taken the insurance industry’s “it’s a feature, not a bug” view of impenetrable claims bureaucracy. Following a contentious hearing with Indiana Department of Transportation Commissioner, Karl Browning, Democrats in the House Roads and Transportation Committee (one of my old committees) also passed a bill which significantly rearranges the allocation of transportation funds — stripping some control from INDOT and giving it to local government. (More here.)
HJR 9 – Election of Supreme Court Justices
Rep. Fry has introduced House Joint Resolution 9 which provides for direct election of state Supreme Court Justices. Of the five, three would be from particular geographic districts and two would be elected at-large. To be eligible, the candidate would have to have been admitted to the practice of law for 10 years or a trial court judge for 5 years.
I’m not a fan. Direct election of the Supreme Court seems like it would politicize the office in a way I don’t think I would like. That said, the current retention system we have seems like something of a farce. I don’t know that any judge has ever lost a retention vote.
Legislative Control Over Economic Stimulus Funds
HB 1656 introduced by Rep. Austin is the subject of an article by Bill Ruthart. The bill specifies that federal economic stimulus dollars cannot be spent except pursuant to legislation adopted by the General Assembly after January 1, 2008 for the purposes specified in the federal economic stimulus package. In other words, the General Assembly does not want the governor spending the money on his own. Senator Kenley was interviewed for Ruthart’s article. He suggested that the Governor should be a partner in deciding how the federal stimulus money was spent. As I read the legislation, he would be — the same as he is in the adoption of any legislation. He can veto appropriations for purposes he does not like. As I read the legislation, however, he would not be able to unilaterally spend the money pursuant to prior appropriations made for other reasons.
It’s Cold
The big story today: it’s *(&#$’n cold out there. Right now, my thermometer is giving me a -5, the Weather Underground page is reporting -14.4, and the local news station is reporting -9, and the windchill is -24.
These extreme temperatures just make everything a lot harder, seems like. Of course, my complaints come as a person with all kinds of modern conveniences. I have a fire going, the furnace going, quality clothing, ample blankets, a decently stocked pantry and refrigerator etc. etc. etc. I can’t imagine what these sorts of conditions were like for our predecessors with ramshackle housing, animal skins for clothes, only fire to keep warm, and having to kill and grow what they ate for themselves. Thank you modern conveniences!
Speaking of fire — and I’m really just rambling now — last night I was prompted to tell my five year old boy the story of Prometheus giving fire to the people. He really enjoyed the bit where Hercules came along to bust Prometheus out of his chains. It’s a good story, but I am also laying some foundations here. At some level the fight between Prometheus and the other gods about whether to let people in on the secret of fire was really about whether people were going to think for themselves and advance themselves through technology on the one hand or whether they were going to slavishly maintain the status quo commanded by the gods on the other. I would really like him to embrace the notion that our fate is self-determined and that people can improve themselves through ingenuity. On another level, I am inoculating him with god stories. If he ultimately embraces a religion, I’ll love him all the same. But, if he does so, hopefully it will be after he comes up with good reasons for assuming that the god of that particular religion is real while Zeus and Odin and Ra and all the other gods worshiped faithfully by other cultures were mere stories.
This started as a post about weather. That, my friends, is some good digression.
The Governor on Property Tax Caps
The Governor, via Tully:
The governor made a strong case for a ballot initiative aimed at determining whether to put recently passed property tax caps in the state constitution. “The only real question,” he said, “is do you trust the people of Indiana to weigh the evidence and make this decision, or don’t you?”
I don’t because:
a) The evidence –real world effects of the caps on local revenue and, therefore, services — is not all in; and won’t be all in for some time;
and
b) Once the evidence is all in, I do not think the average voter will take more than a superficial look at it. I suspect if you quizzed the average voter, most could not tell you in detail how local government functioned or how it was funded.
And that’s all right. That’s why we have a representative government. Because our citizens, while having a duty to keep informed to some degree, have more important things to do than get into the weeds of local government finance. That’s why legislating property tax caps is a better idea than engraving it into the Constitution based on popular, and possibly superficial, anti-tax sentiment. That’s also why the General Assembly has been given a significant gate-keeping function with respect to which public questions get put on the ballot.
So, I say to our legislators, don’t shirk your duties with a glib “let the voters decide” response. If you vote for a Constitutional property tax cap, do it because you feel you have deliberated with all of the necessary facts, and based on that deliberation can explain what effects this will have on local government, its finances, and the services it will provide and have decided that these caps are the best thing for Indiana, not just now, but for the next century.
On Liberty, God, and Morality
This is going to be a quick hit with no real answers; but I came across a couple of very interesting items this morning on the topics of God, Liberty, and Morality.
The first is Ed Brayton at Dispatches from the Culture Wars who asks “what do we think of the notion of a God given right to liberty (or equality) in order to make such rights “unalienable”? Attaching something to God is probably the only way to make such a concept we really like trump all other claims.”
While chewing on that, I stumbled across a page written by Wil Forbis entitled “searching for the Moral Directive in The Watchmen.” Since I read “The Watchmen” in the Spring of 1990, I have found a particular monologue by the character Rorschach to be very compelling. In that monologue, he says:
This rudderless world is not shaped by vague metaphysical forces. It is not God who kills the children. Not fate that butchers them or destiny that feeds them to the dogs. It’s us. Only us.
I suspect that formulation very well may be correct. It is up to us to assign value to our actions and the consequences of our actions. The proper yardsticks for doing so are not terribly clear, but I think it is up to us to create those yardsticks and apply them.
When considering Rorschach’s proclamation, Forbis turns to Yale Professor Arthur Allen Leff who wrote:
I want to believe —and so do you— in a complete, transcendent, and immanent set of propositions about right and wrong, findable rules that authoritatively and unambiguously direct us how to live righteously.
. . .
I also want to believe —and so do you —in no such thing, but rather that we are wholly free, not only to choose for ourselves what we ought to do, but to decide for ourselves, individually and as a species, what we ought to be. What we want, Heaven help us, is simultaneously to be perfectly ruled and perfectly free, that is, at the same time to discover the right and good and to create it.
Like I said, no answers from me at this point (if ever), but certainly some good stuff to chew on.
For-Profit Insurance: The 800# Gorilla of Health Care
South Shore Progressive posted a piece from Dr. Robert Stone of Bloomington, IN who suggested that for-profit insurance companies are the 800 pound gorilla in reforming our dying health care system.
Poor regulation has contributed to the overall financial crisis, no doubt. In the case of the health insurance industry’s predicament, at least two other forces are undermining its viability: the steadily declining numbers of people in employer-sponsored health plans and the skyrocketing costs of individual health insurance plans.
Private health insurance, with its rising premiums, co-pays, deductibles, exclusions, and so on, is becoming increasingly unaffordable for individuals, families and businesses. The private model of financing care is no longer sustainable; it is dying.
We simply can no longer afford to have these for-profit companies dominate our health care system. They ARE the problem, and retaining their inefficient, greedy business practices should not be part of the solution.
Instead, we should turn to the “other 800-pound gorilla†in the room – the elegantly simple solution staring us in the face: Medicare for all. Medicare is the universal government financed (“single payerâ€) health care system we have already for everyone age 65 and older. We have over 40 years’ experience with it. Simply replace for-profit insurance with Medicare for everyone.
Dr. Stone is a leader of Hoosiers for a Commonsense Health Plan.
Geithner’s Tax Issue
Given that I had heard about the tax problems of Treasury Secretary nominee, Timothy Geithner, about three times this evening without once hearing them described, I thought I’d post a summary of his non-payment of taxes as reported by the Wall Street Journal:
The tax issue relates to Mr. Geithner’s work for the International Monetary Fund between 2001 and 2004. As an American citizen working for the IMF, Mr. Geithner was technically considered self-employed and was required to pay Social Security and Medicare taxes for himself as both an employer and an employee.
The IMF and World Bank reimburse employees, including U.S. citizens, for their U.S. income taxes, and make payments on a quarterly basis to cover those liabilities. They don’t, however, make contributions toward Social Security and Medicare taxes, which individuals are expected to pay on their own.
HB 1317 – Abstinence Only Education
Rep. Linda Lawson has introduced HB 1317 concerning notice to parents about abstinence only education. If a school decides to go the abstinence-only education route, it would have to send out the following notice:
“Your child is receiving abstinence-only human sexuality education.
Abstinence-only education does not teach students how to prevent pregnancy or sexually transmitted diseases other than by remaining abstinent.
Your child is not receiving the following:
(A) Information on methods, other than abstinence, for preventing pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS.
(B) Medically accurate instruction on the risks and benefits, including safety and efficacy, of Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved methods for:
(i) reducing the risk of contracting sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS; and
(ii) preventing pregnancy.
(C) Medically accurate instruction regarding the correct use of FDA approved methods for:
(i) reducing the risk of contracting sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS; and
(ii) preventing pregnancy.
(D) Instruction that provides lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender students with the necessary skills for making and implementing responsible decisions about relationships and sexuality, including the use of all effective methods to prevent sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS.
(E) Instruction that provides sexually active students with the necessary skills for making and implementing responsible decisions about relationships and sexuality, including the use of all effective methods to prevent pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS.
You have the right to review the abstinence-only curriculum in its entirety. Written and audiovisual educational materials used in abstinence-only education are available for inspection.You have the right to excuse your child from all or parts of abstinence-only instruction.
You have the right to be involved in your child’s education.”.
Might as well require them to send out a notice saying, “Hi, we’re being criminally negligent with your child’s education. How soon would you like our resignation?” It would probably be better to skip sex education altogether than an abstinence-only curriculum that might give some parents the illusion that their children’s educational needs in these areas were being fulfilled.
HB 1421 – Death Penalty Moratorium
Representative Vernon Smith has introduced HB 1421 which would impose a moratorium on the death penalty through July 1, 2012; and establish a 15 member commission to study the death penalty and make recommendations prior to January 1, 2012.
As an initial matter, I do not like the legislation because it has a “findings” section. I don’t like legislation that makes proclamations. I want nuts & bolts language that tells me who gets to do what to whom and under what circumstances.
But, I can get along with its premise well enough. Personally, I have no opposition to the general philosophy of the death penalty. Certain actions are bad enough that they should result in the forfeiture of one’s life. As implemented, however, I do have concerns. It seems like there is a non-trivial risk of convicting the wrong person of a capital crime. That needs to be fixed.
That said, I predict this legislation is going nowhere.
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 304
- 305
- 306
- 307
- 308
- …
- 690
- Next Page »