Deanna Martin, writing for the Associated Press, reports that Senator Long is indicating that the Governor’s local government restructuring plan would probably have to be voluntary to pass the Senate. Among other things, the restructuring plan calls for a unitary executive to replace the 3-person board of commissioners and calls for the county council to pick up a lot of the legislative duties currently performed by the board of commissioners.
Seems to me that the further one gets away from the capitol, the more important local government control becomes to people. As this debate progresses, I want people to pay attention to something — and I’ll pay attention myself. Let’s see how many people stomping up and down about how necessary and good mandatory local government restructuring is come from Indianapolis, and let’s see how many are from other places.
Indianapolis/Marion County already has county government a lot like that proposed under the restructuring and, perhaps just as importantly, state government sits in Indianapolis. So, when the State adopts legislation, it feels a lot less like mandates coming from a foreign power.
So, I want to see how many voices in favor of mandatory restructuring are coming from places not dominated by big cities, with functioning and influential boards of commissioners, and mostly out of the shadow of the Capitol City. My bias is that the Tippecanoe County Board of Commissioners has, in my opinion, been an excellent governing body since I moved out of Indianapolis to the Lafayette area. In that time, I recall one commissioner with whom I did not usually agree, but the other two balanced her out. I can’t imagine if that commissioner — or say a county level Blagojevich — took control of the unitary executive. For that matter, is the streamlined non-leadership of Mayor Ballard or the dysfunctional legislative body that is the City-County Council really being held up as a model of government for the rest of the counties? A mandatory model?
Let’s just say I have reservations at this point. I’ll need some convincing on the point of why I should prefer a mandate from the General Assembly for that model of government to replace what I have currently in Tippecanoe County. And voices outside of Indianapolis will probably be more convincing than those within.