The Lafayette Journal & Courier has a reasonable editorial on the Voter ID law recently struck down as unconstitutional because it treated absentee voters more leniently than in-person voters. The J&C suggests that legislators simply go back and treat absentee voters the same as in-person voters.
Rather than appeal Thursday’s ruling, it might be a better route for lawmakers to close the loopholes and adopt a new law that applies uniformly to all voters.
Given that many of the state’s problems with voter fraud have occurred with absentee ballots, it seems reasonable that the photo ID rule apply to them, or that some other method of verifying identification be adopted.
Reasonable as it is, it starts with the flawed premise that this was ever fundamentally about combatting voter fraud. Consider that the law’s proponents rejected proposed amendments to make this law apply to absentee voters and could not point to any real life instances of fraud that this would have stopped, certainly not any that had any particular impact on an actual election.
These items don’t fit into the narrative where Voter ID proponents are crusading to protect the integrity of the electoral system from the scourge of fraud. In my misspent youth, I experimented with a little Ayn Rand. I’ve discarded most of that rubbish but one quote that stuck with me, overblown as it is, was this: “Contradictions do not exist. Whenever you think you are facing a contradiction, check your premises. You will find that one of them is wrong.” O.k., so that’s just an overbearing way of saying that when things don’t fit together, you ought to check your premises.
The facts fit together a lot better if you discard the premise that voter fraud was the purpose of the Voter ID law and replace it with the premise that one political party, temporarily ascendant, saw fit to pass a law that would shave a percentage point or two off the other side’s voters. The Republicans made a calculation that the voters who would: a) vote in person; and b) not have identification would skew toward the Democrats. That calculus changes if you apply the ID requirement to those who vote absentee. Therefore, the absentee voters were not subjected to the same level of scrutiny.
If the Journal & Courier’s premise is correct, I would expect simple legislation to correct the disparate treatment. If my premise is correct, I would expect a trip to the Supreme Court and a lot of public gnashing of teeth that never seems to address why absentee voters should be subjected to less scrutiny than in-person voters.