For all the fear mongering about voter fraud, it has proven amazingly elusive. TPM Muckraker has the story of some possible voter fraud in New York. The specific details are mildly interesting but not of much importance to Indiana. Basically, it involves a pissing match by proxy between Democrats and Republicans in a third-party primary in a county-level election. The important take away with respect to Indiana is that the fraud appears to have involved absentee ballots. Yet more evidence that, contrary to Gov. Daniels’ assertions, it is not “preposterous” or even partisan to require greater or at least equal security standards for absentee ballots as opposed to in-person voting.
Kennedy on Voter ID Decision
Sheila Kennedy has a good column in the Indianapolis Star about the Indiana Court of Appeals’ recent decision on the Voter ID law, Gov. Daniels responsive outburst about “partisan judges” in particular. And I’m not at all influenced in that assessment by the fact that she quoted something from a previous entry here. Nope, not at all.
[G]ov. Mitch Daniels was quick to accuse all three judges who issued the opinion of “playing politics.” This rhetoric is unfortunate on a number of levels. It betrays unfamiliarity with the arguments involved, and — worse — paints judges as no more than partisans in robes. Such attacks, as the Indiana Bar Association pointed out, undermine the legitimacy of the judicial system.
Daniels’ intemperate reaction also appears to confirm suspicions that the voter ID law was itself a partisan effort.
Debtors’ Prisons
Roberta Heiman has an article in the Evansville Courier Press on a topic with which I am intimately familiar – collection of debts in a small claims court. Apparently things run a little differently in southern Indiana. There appears to be a local practice where judgment debtors are held in contempt for defaulting on payment agreements. The article mentions a case out of Perry County I discussed awhile back where the judge apparently threatened the judgment debtor with jail if she didn’t make a payment arrangement.
It also mentions a situation in Evansville where a judgment debtor was going to be held in contempt for failing to honor an agreed order on a prior payment arrangement.
Debtors prisons aren’t permitted in Indiana. In the counties where I practice, non-payment isn’t going to earn you a contempt citation. What does happen, quite frequently, is that people get served with orders to appear and testify as to their income and assets, fail to appear, and then have writs issued for their arrest to compel their testimony. A person can also be held in contempt for failing to appear if they cannot show good cause for their failure.
Even though I think that debtors’ rights advocates are correct, generally, when they protest the practice of locking people up for non-payment; they go too far when they suggest that creditors can’t force them back into court repeatedly to inquire about their income and assets. A creditor is not going to have independent knowledge of the debtors’ financial situation. I can’t tell you the number of times I have let a judgment sit for awhile, and call the judgment debtor into court after many months, only to find that the person is no longer employed but held a job for a period of time between court dates. Had I been forcing the person into court every month, I would have discovered income subject to garnishment.
Returning to the southern Indiana practice of holding people in contempt for failing to abide by a payment agreement – certainly I think it’s inappropriate if, during the period of non-payment, the debtor never had any attachable income or assets; for example, if all they ever had during this period was Social Security income. But what if the person entered into an agreement resulting in a court order to pay $100 per month; had garnishable income in excess of the $100 per month; but refused to pay anyway. It seems to me that, in that situation, there is a case to be made for contempt proceedings: the court has ordered you to do something, you have failed to do it, and you cannot show any legal excuse for your failure.
In any case, if you hear one of these “debtors prisons” stories, always pay attention to what, precisely, led to the person’s arrest. I’ve had any number of judgment debtors complain about being arrested for a debt when the reason for their arrest was their failure to obey a court order to appear and testify as to their income and assets. My somewhat unsympathetic attitude over the years has been that, if you don’t have a job, generally you can make time to go to court.
IN-08: Assessing Ellsworth’s Competition for 2010
Thomas Langhorn has an article in the Evansville Courier Press about GOP hopes to capture a seat which seem to be pinned on Dr. Larry Bucshon who opposes a public insurance option as a means of fixing our health care system. I suppose the way you combat a candidate like that is to point out that, of course he opposes any real fix to the health care problem — after all, he’s doing well enough under the current system. (Assuming, of course, that Dr. Bucshon has been prospering under the current system — I don’t actually know anything about him.)
The Courier Press article mentions that no opponent has anything like a campaign organization comparable to what Ellsworth had at a similar point in the election cycle when he unseated John Hostetler. The article mentions the common wisdom that 2010 will be a bad year for Democrats – and you would expect that based on the fact that governing is always harder than campaigning – but, as of yet, there is not much in the way of polling data that suggests Republicans are convincing people they have a better idea for fixing what ails us. That might change in the next few months, but memories of the last 10 years are still pretty fresh in people’s minds.
Americans Not Very Good at Foreign Languages
The Associated Press has an article that doesn’t surprise me at all.
American students are falling far behind their international counterparts in learning second languages, creating economic disadvantages for U.S. businesses and raising national security concerns.
Virtually all European and Asian elementary students study a second language, but 97 percent of Ohio and Kentucky students do not because their schools don’t offer it.
Foreign languages are seen as something of a luxury. Our political culture tends to hold other countries in disdain. News reports about the rest of the world are pretty limited. Opportunities for Americans to travel in foreign countries are relatively infrequent. And English, for the time being, is the world’s lingua franca. School systems can’t see a lot of reason to emphasize foreign languages and students can’t see a lot of reason to learn them.
FSSA Privatization “Failure”
Eric Bradner, writing for the Evansville Courier Press, has a good account of the State Budget Committee’s hearing on the privatization contract which transferred handling of welfare applications from the Family and Social Services Administration (FSSA) to IBM and Affiliated Computer Systems, Inc. (ACS). (ACS, quite coincidentally, I’m sure, was former FSSA chief, Mitch Roob’s former employer.)
The privatization has cost the state of Indiana a pile of money and has led to chronic complaints of lost documentation and long waiting times. Unlike the former system, there is no dedicated caseworker for applicants, so they’re at the mercy of whoever happens to pick up the phone after they finally get out of automated phone hell.
As I’ve mentioned before, this bureaucracy seems like a design flaw if your goal is to deliver services to Hoosiers in need. On the other hand, the system seems less flawed if your goal is to transfer taxpayer money to preferred associates and to discourage poor people from applying for and receiving benefits. If that’s the goal, then those lost documents and increased wait times seem less like bugs and more like features.
Tomorrow is not promised
It’s been a rough month for Richmond kids I went to school with. Today, I found out that Cari (Spitz) Ashford, a 1991 graduate of RHS, died of cancer this past Tuesday. This comes on the heels of the death of Tony Feller (RHS Class of ’90) about eight days earlier.
Again, Cari wasn’t someone with whom I was close. I hadn’t spoken with her for about 15 years. Mostly I remember her as a sweet girl from high school I worked with on the high school paper and took to a dance once. But, even as distant as these two are from my current circle of acquaintances, their deaths in rapid succession have the power to make me angry. Both were fine people with a lot to offer the world. Times like these, I tend to think that there seem to be a lot of people without so much to offer who are in fine health. So, alert the media: “Life is not fair.”
My temper has cooled about that fact, but it’s not entirely gone. I remember when I was 19, a friend of my sister died in a motorcycle accident. I remember seething when I came across this one real piece of shit guy who worked with me in the warehouse that summer. It seemed abominable to me that this guy was drawing breath while my friend was being buried at age 21 or 22. Age has a way of numbing you to life’s inequities.
Just one more reminder to hug my family and recall that, such problems as I may have are pretty insignificant. Rest in peace, Cari, and strength to your family.
Kelo v. City of New London Revisited
A friend of mine passed along this AP article on the fate of the property acquired by the City of New London that was the subject of the Kelo v. City of New London case handed down by the Supreme Court in 2005.
Turns out the City didn’t need the property that badly after all. The development for which the City exercised the power of eminent domain seems to have collapsed.
Weeds, glass, bricks, pieces of pipe and shingle splinters have replaced the knot of aging homes at the site of the nation’s most notorious eminent domain project.
There are a few signs of life: Feral cats glare at visitors from a miniature jungle of Queen Anne’s lace, thistle and goldenrod. Gulls swoop between the lot’s towering trees and the adjacent sewage treatment plant.
. . .
In New London the city’s prized economic development plan has fallen apart as the economy crumbled.The Corcoran Jennison Cos., a Boston-based developer, had originally locked in exclusive rights to develop nearly the entire northern half of the Fort Trumbull peninsula.
But those rights expired in June 2008, despite multiple extensions, because the firm was unable to secure financing, according to President Marty Jones.
In July, backers halted fundraising for the project’s crown jewel, a proposed $60 million, 60,000-square-foot Coast Guard museum.
The legal decision didn’t bother me. The project, as described in the Supreme Court case — as opposed to the media reports about the Supreme Court case, did not strike me as such a departure from tradition. It was a big project with a lot of public use and, yes, some private use, but it was not a simple matter of seizing land from one person and handing it to another.
But, jeeze, make sure you can get the job done once the land is acquired. This is a horrible waste. Sometimes I’ll tell a client or potential client, “Are you really sure you want to do this? Because this sounds like the kind of case where nobody is going to win but me.” Looks like this ended up being one of those cases.
(Even More) Ominous Clouds for the Mortgage Industry
What if the mortgage industry screwed up its legal right to foreclose on (give or take) 60 million homes? That’s the potential consequence of Landmark National Bank v. Kesler (Kan. 2009). The Kansas Supreme Court can’t issue binding precedent for the rest of the country, but the reasoning here is not to be easily ignored.
I don’t fully understand the ins and outs of this process, so look elsewhere for an authoritative discussion, but generally the issue is that a number of lenders set up an entity called “Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc.” (MERS – the Wikipedia article seems informative but not neutral.) As I understand it, this entity purports to be the mortgagee of record to a note on a loan secured by real estate. Lenders who are participants in the MERS program can buy and sell interests in mortgages and, I suppose, portions thereof without having to do a lot of paperwork and recording that assigns the mortgage to one person and then another as the financial obligation is traded about. So, Bank A lends the money to a Buyer to purchase a home and has the Buyer sign a mortgage in favor of MERS. As a participant in the MERS program, Bank A can then sell the mortgage to Bank B without having to do a lot of paperwork assigning the mortgage to Bank B and recording that assignment in the county recorders office.
The facts described by the Kansas Supreme Court are probably typical of a MERS mortgage:
The second mortgage lies at the core of this appeal. That mortgage document stated that the mortgage was made between Kesler–the “Mortgagor” and “Borrower”–and MERS, which was acting “solely as nominee for Lender, as hereinafter defined, and Lender’s successors and assigns.” The document then identified Millennia as the “Lender.” At some subsequent time, the mortgage may have been assigned to Sovereign and Sovereign may have taken physical possession of the note, but that assignment was not registered in Ford County.
The problem with MERS is that the mortgage (granting the power to foreclose in the even of default) is severed from the note (creating the obligation by which default is possible). The Kansas Supreme Court describes what can happen when the the mortgage is severed from the note:
The relationship that MERS has to Sovereign is more akin to that of a straw man than to a party possessing all the rights given a buyer. A mortgagee and a lender have intertwined rights that defy a clear separation of interests, especially when such a purported separation relies on ambiguous contractual language. The law generally understands that a mortgagee is not distinct from a lender: a mortgagee is “[o]ne to whom property is mortgaged: the mortgage creditor, or lender.” Black’s Law Dictionary 1034 (8th ed. 2004). By statute, assignment of the mortgage carries with it the assignment of the debt. K.S.A. 58-2323. Although MERS asserts that, under some situations, the mortgage document purports to give it the same rights as the lender, the document consistently refers only to rights of the lender, including rights to receive notice of litigation, to collect payments, and to enforce the debt obligation. The document consistently limits MERS to acting “solely” as the nominee of the lender.
Indeed, in the event that a mortgage loan somehow separates interests of the note and the deed of trust, with the deed of trust lying with some independent entity, the mortgage may become unenforceable.
“The practical effect of splitting the deed of trust from the promissory note is to make it impossible for the holder of the note to foreclose, unless the holder of the deed of trust is the agent of the holder of the note. [Citation omitted.] Without the agency relationship, the person holding only the note lacks the power to foreclose in the event of default. The person holding only the deed of trust will never experience default because only the holder of the note is entitled to payment of the underlying obligation. [Citation omitted.] The mortgage loan becomes ineffectual when the note holder did not also hold the deed of trust.” Bellistri v. Ocwen Loan Servicing, LLC, 284 S.W.3d 619, 623 (Mo. App. 2009).
Or, in short, “If MERS is only the mortgagee, without ownership of the mortgage instrument, it does not have an enforceable right.” But, if MERS does have enforceable rights to the underlying note, it could find itself embroiled in regulations that apply to mortgage bankers.
Matt Taibbi has a blog entry on this likening the mortgage industry to a giant criminal enterprise. He also notes that, more generally, the mortgage industry has been incredibly sloppy with its record keeping. This has allowed debtors to successfully challenge a lender’s right to foreclose in some cases. These are people who have received a benefit from money lent and who have failed on their promises to repay the money, but the lender (or whoever is currently holding the bag) can’t recover because they can’t prove they actually own the debt.
I don’t know if severing the note from the mortgage has a similar effect in Indiana or if MERS mortgages use the same language in Indiana. I suspect we’ll see an increase in challenges along these lines as attorneys become more attuned to the issues and courts analyze evidence about chain of title with a more critical eye. Glancing at some of the cases, I saw a case where the Northern District of Illinois shrugged off a similar challenge based on some affidavits from people associated with MERS and no serious rebuttal or opposition from the mortgage-debtor.
If MERS mortgages were deemed to be unenforceable, it could obviously have major repercussions. I ran a quick and dirty search on the Tippecanoe County court system and found more than 500 cases where “Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc.” was a party.
Update: Per a comment, here is the link to an entry Advance Indiana did on the subject a month or two ago.
St. Joseph County Mandate
St. Joseph County is having a trial over a judicial mandate to increase salaries for judicial staff and improvements at a juvenile detention center. The Indiana Law Blog, as per usual, has some good coverage of this issue.
[Judge] Nemeth and county officials are in a legal fight over $313,000 in funding the county refused to release in 2008 to renovate parts of the JJC. The County Council and county commissioners had approved the judge’s request to transfer the money from an unspent personnel fund, but county commissioner Bob Kovach later refused to sign a requisition order.
Nemeth issued a judicial mandate order to obtain the money.
He also issued a mandate seeking to use probation services fees to fund raises for the juvenile/probate court’s executive secretary, fiscal officer, JJC director and five other managers. The proposed raises range from 10 percent increases to nearly 34 percent.
I’ve held forth on other mandate cases over the years. (See, e.g., here and here and here.) The problem, as I see it, is that judges are a little bit county and a little bit state. They can use their state created judicial powers in service of their county administrative functions. Other county department heads can’t just order the county council to dig into the county general fund and cough up more money for county employees. State judges can.
The Indiana Judicial Conference recently laid out a strategic plan (pdf) that touches on the mandate issue as well as a number of other things. Consideration is being given to centralizing administration and funding of the courts. Currently judges, magistrates, and prosecutors are paid by the state while the rest of the court staff and other administrative expenses are paid by the county.
Where we want to be:
We can do better by distributing resources across the State in a more equitable manner by pursuing centralized funding. More Hoosier citizens will benefit, particularly in counties without a large tax base.
The Division of State Court Administration is pursuing three studies regarding costs associated with centralized funding. The studies are by Larry DeBoer of Purdue University, the Indiana University SPEA school, and a local consultant. These studies are in progress, and we do not know what the results ultimately will be until these studies are complete. At this point, we cannot say centralized funding will definitely create taxpayer savings. We can say, with certainty, efficiencies will result by combining resources and eliminating duplicated efforts.
We have yet to address many complex issues, including arrangements for state court personnel to use county facilities, whether to convert court employees to state employees, and if so, which court employees should be converted. We would have to address court, probation, and security staff, public defenders and pauper counsel, as well as guardian ad litems and court appointed special advocates, interpreters and other specialized court functions. Some judicial officers who now work as commissioners and referees would become state funded Magistrate Judges under a centralized funding scenario.
We will also have to address a method for governance, budgeting, and allocating assets. It would be premature to render an opinion on how this funding change would work until such time as the three studies have been completed. Even without the results from the studies, we believe centralized funding will eliminate duplication and increase efficiency, as well as distribute resources in a uniform manner among all counties.
Generally speaking, I would suggest that the power to spend should be coupled with the duty to fund. If a state official is going to order that something be paid, then the state should be responsible for raising the funds. In the South Bend context, it’s one thing for the judge to say that staff salaries ought to be raised or that the juvenile justice center ought to be maintained better. I’m sure he’s right. But other things in the county need funding as well and, to me, it doesn’t seem quite right that the judge’s concerns get to jump to the front of the line simply by virtue of the judicial mandate.
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 259
- 260
- 261
- 262
- 263
- …
- 690
- Next Page »