Craig has an excellent post up about what lies ahead in the race between McCain and Obama. First will be experience. But that probably won’t play so well since the kind of experience we’ve seen lately from McCain, Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld et. al. hasn’t lead us to good places.
As for the second:
Obama is quite new. The public doesn’t know him very well. That is why 10-13% of Americans believe he is secretly a Muslim. His patriotism will continue to be questioned. There will be whisperings about whether or not he understands “real Americansâ€. It will be noted that he is in fact a Christian, but questions will be raised as to whether or not he is the “right kind†of Christian. I for one cannot remember any presidential election in which the undergraduate thesis of a candidate’s wife was under scrutiny, but that is exactly what has happened this year. The1985 senior thesis of Michelle Obama was a regular topic of discussion on the Sean Hannity radio show. It should be noted that Hannity also misquoted the document in order to attribute words to Michelle Obama that were not her own.
“He’s not like us” will be the beat of the drum.
Also worth reading this morning, Ruth Holladay points us to a New York Times article entitled “Calm in the Swirl of History”:
A reporter reads aloud from the novelist Darryl Pinckney’s essay in The New York Review of Books. Mr. Obama, the novelist writes, “comes across as someone who stored away for future consideration practically everything that was ever said to him, and who had a talent for watchfulness, part of the extraordinary armor he developed at an early age.â€
Mr. Obama nods. That’s intriguing. But he prefers his own riff, which not incidentally trains the eye not on him but on his crowds. “I love when I’m shaking hands on a rope line andâ€â€” he mimes the motion, hand over hand — “I see little old white ladies and big burly black guys and Latino girls and all their hands are entwining. They’re feeding on each other as much as on me.”
He shrugs; it’s that distancing eye of the author.
“It’s like I’m just the excuse.â€
With McCain’s experience, one can only be confused, because he takes opposing positions on so many issues as time passes. If he’s elected, one could only guess at his reactions to events.
In my view, he had to sell what remained of his soul to get the Republican nomination. Religious fundamentalists, Bush’s red ink, and tax cuts for the wealthy, and the Iraq War will be firmly tied as albatrosses around his neck.
Obama has a thin record of experience. People don’t know him from Abraham. Thus, his past associations are very important to judge the character of the man.
Being a “community activist” (translation: Communist), never holding a job in the private sector, associating with all kinds of South Side Chicago radicals, the connections to Chicago political insiders like Resko and Axlerod, with a very influential wife who is a nutjob, who herself has only had a job as a “diversity coordinator”, etc. etc. etc. are all very relevant as to who Obama really is under that slick marketing job.
McCain is McCain. His inconsistancy is his appeal to independents. He takes issues one at a time and judges them on their merits, independent of ideology. He has no ideology, which is why we conservatives don’t like him. But that’s the appeal to the “moderates”. So be it.
Taxes are a huge, huge issue. The tax increases that Obama is speaking openly of are quite large. They’ll have a big impact on people’s everyday lives. I’m not rich, I don’t really have any capital gains in taxable accounts, but when you talk about uncapping the Socialist Insecurity payroll tax, or going back to the pre-Bush marginal tax rates, or eliminating the child tax credit, that’s real money to me. Thousands of dollars.
Now that the Hillary and Barry show is over, we can start to focus on the real ideas that Obama has out there. McCain has focused on the foreign policy ideas, but the domestic ideas are just as poorly thought out.
As far as taxes go, everything I’ve heard from Obama involves rolling back Bush tax cuts that benefited those making in excess of at least $100,000. I think the payroll taxes are currently capped at the first $95,000 or so. So, you’d have to be making more than that for the uncapping to affect you.
$95k per year doesn’t make you rich, but it puts you in the top few percentage points of the population in terms of income.
As for the “never held a job in the private sector,” that’s just factually incorrect. He worked for a year out of undergraduate school as an editor for Business International Corporation and as an attorney in the private sector for several years. I don’t know whether his work as community organizer or as an author counts as “public sector.”
For what it’s worth, McCain’s private sector work is even less extensive.
As for the “never held a job in the private sector,†that’s just factually incorrect. He worked for a year out of undergraduate school as an editor for Business International Corporation and as an attorney in the private sector for several years. I don’t know whether his work as community organizer or as an author counts as “public sector.â€
Didn’t know about the editor position. That’s not what Obama has said. He said that he got our of Harvard and went right into “community organizing” for a mere $12,000 a year in 1985 dollars, which is equivalent to $27k dollars today. Right at the median income. What a sacrifice.
Who knew that Communists were so well paid?
Community organizing is not a real job.
For what it’s worth, McCain’s private sector work is even less extensive.
Right. But his military service and long legislative career puts him on a different plain that Obama.
Obama has little real life experience, and his legislative career has been short and lackluster. You can’t judge him by his accomplishments, because he has none. That forces you to take a look at his associations, which are not good.
He has a history of radical associations. That’s who he really is. Now why should I trust that he’s not going to govern like a radical?
$95k per year doesn’t make you rich, but it puts you in the top few percentage points of the population in terms of income.
$95k is a pretty tame salary for anyone with a college education and some time in the workforce. Hell, on the coasts it isn’t even a good salary. You can’t live in Manhattan on that salary.
Jacking up the payroll tax is going to hit millions of people. Lots of them, like me, are just getting into that range after years of hard work getting an education and climbing the corporate ladder.
And now along comes Obama, who has been making that kind of money for over a decade, and now he’s going to tell me that I need to pay more taxes? No way.
If deficits are a problem, cut Socialist Insecurity and Medicare. The government has enough money without taking more from me and my family.
Buzzcut,
Shut the fuck up. Take your whiny, paranoid, right-wing garbage and leave. Go vote for McSame in November. Better yet, don’t. We don’t need ignorant, bleating douchebags ruining the vote.
But I’m sure Damian meant that in a good way, in the spirit of pure constructive engagement…
Damn, Damian! I always imagined it was just a matter of time before Buzzcut caused someone on here to snap…!
Doug has imposed some “play nice” rules on me, so I have respected those wishes and not said some of the things to Buzzcut that I’d like. I mostly try to ignore him ever since he called me an idiot a while back. Either way, it’s hard to debate someone who is so uninformed, but I do often wonder why he comes ’round these parts. I figure he likes to be seen where the smart people hang out. (Unfortunately, his comments do not help his cause.)
I mostly try to ignore him ever since he called me an idiot a while back.
I most certainly did not. Never used the i word, or really any derogatory word.
To the best of my memory.
Shut the fuck up. Take your whiny, paranoid, right-wing garbage and leave. Go vote for McSame in November. Better yet, don’t. We don’t need ignorant, bleating douchebags ruining the vote.
Kiss your kids with that mouth?
Do you guys really like to debate people that agree with you?
For my part, I don’t often agree with Buzzcut, but I like having him around. I’d also ask for folks to lay off the personal attacks. The ideas are easy enough to attack. (Sorry Buzzcut, I couldn’t resist.)
You are far too kind to Buzzcut, Doug. Whether you remember or not, you did call me an idiot or a moron at some point when you attacked teachers.
So, did he specifically call you, the individual, a name, or was it a generic insult directed at teachers in general?
And, my wife is a teacher, Buzzcut. She’s not an idiot, or moron either.
Whether you remember or not, you did call me an idiot or a moron at some point when you attacked teachers.
Hmm. Don’t recall. If I did, I appologize.
Doug, I agree, it is nice having Buzzcut around, even though I often disagree. And I agree 100% with the sentiment that it does no good to argue with people you agree with. Buzz, you add to the debate, and that’s great. Now, with that said…
Why does community organizer = communist and community organizer = not a real job? The guy had a private sector job after undergrad, hated it, went to Harvard Law School and could have made a very healthy living (with a “real job”) in the private sector but chose to give back to the community. I, for one, don’t hold that against him.
And I sincerely think that your “since he has no experience we must judge him by his associations” meme is entirely disingenuous. First, I disagree with the “since he has no experience” portion, but even if I granted that the second part doesn’t follow. And even if the “we must judge him by his associations” part made sense, you are cherry picking his associations!
I can only assume you are talking about Rev. Wright (yup, he’s crazy, but he’s certainly done more good for people in his community than you or me), or Bill Ayers (yup, he’s got a radical past, but he’s now a Distingued Professor (that’s the actual title) at the U of C where Obama taught. I also fail to see how hosting a single fundraiser 12 years ago makes him an associate.)
I strongly suspect instead that you won’t vote for a Democrat, and therefore have arrived at this particular reason, because you’ve been able to formulate it around the current Democrat.
Anyhoo, I’m sure it won’t convince you Buzz or change your mind, but that’s my $0.02, sorry it’s kinda long.
I’ve lived in and around Chicago for 10 years now. I’ve known of Obama since before his first Senate primary. His associations have been with the Chicago Southside nutjobs: Jesse Jackson, Farrakhan, Pfleger, Wright, and James Meeks, in addition to Ayers. These guys are all powerbrokers in Obama’s old state senate district. But they are hardly mainstream individuals.
I think Meeks is the next shoe to drop for Obama. Despite running the biggest church on the south side and being an elected official, Meeks has said some really bad things, especially with regards to Jews. He’s as nutty as Wright.
Regarding community activists, sorry, it is just not a real job. Hell, I’m a community activist. I volunteer for a couple of organizations like Lions and Rotary. I have a real problem with the professionalization of something that should be a charity run by volunteers.
Okay, I’m baiting you guys by calling Obama a Communist. But if Vladimir Lennin were alive today on the South Side of Chicago, he would call himself a community activist.
And, point of fact, Obama’s big influence in community activism was Saul Alinsky, a Communist. Big C.
Would I vote for a Democrat? I voted for Slick Wiley the first time. Haven’t voted Democrat since. But then, I am a registered Republican! Is that so strange that I prefer… Republicans?
Just, for what it’s worth, I seem to recall Saul Alinsky being cited by Hillary Clinton as an influence.
From Alinsky’s Wikipedia entry:
I think that you may be right. Hillary may have actually worked with Alinsky, where Obama came to the South Side 10 years after Alinsky died.
I like Buzzy too, because he lives in this same warped (politically) area in which I live.
Plus he really gets my brother’s goat sometimes;-) (Love ya, bro!)
I don’t often agree with him, but he does at least add food for thought to the blog. Politically I was a lemming for too long, and appreciate hearing both sides being discussed (usually) thoughtfully.
Respectfully I must add to this post that we will be hard-pressed to find anyone who does not have some major skeleton in his/her closet; especially who is running for national office. Hell, even I have some! (And no I won’t share! But none that make me unworthy to serve as pastor.) And BTW Tony Rezko was just found guilty on most of his charges. Gov. Blowhard (can’t spell his real name) of Illinois is supposed to be on the news soon to give his “impressions” on his buddy being convicted.
I think the problem that I have with Buzzcut is that he’s lacking a little thing I like to call tact. He’s abrasive and rude, using attack language whenever necessary.
I guess if you think George W. Bush has done a phenomenal job, then by all means, vote Republican. Vote for McSame McPlain. I don’t like the high gas prices, the deficit spending, the economic downward spiral, the crumbling schools, the horrific way we’ve screwed up our international relations, and politicians trying to make their small government fit into my uterus and into my bedroom. I think it’s an abomination, and I’ve had enough.
Would I vote for a Republican? Absolutely. If I thought a Republican candidate had policies that were good for America, then I would vote that way. John McCain is not that candidate. A vote for John McCain is a vote for George Bush. I am not about to help repeat a mistake that I didn’t make the first time around.
Oops. I’m well known to be “tactless”. Does that mean I’m in trouble too?
Amy-I think he’s lived up here by Chicago a bit too long;-)
fwiw, Alinsky was well known as a fierce anti-Communist but rightwingers call anybody to the left of Bob Dole a Communist (and they have their suspicions about Elizabeth!)
I think the problem that I have with Buzzcut is that he’s lacking a little thing I like to call tact.
“Obnoxious and unpersuasive”.
fwiw, Alinsky was well known as a fierce anti-Communist
Yeah, I shouldn’t have said that he was a “Big C” Communist. He wasn’t working secretrly with Moscow.
I think that you would properly describe him as a fellow traveler. You look at that Wikipedia article, about his theory of “agitation”, and I just think that you’re talking about a kinder, gentler communism.
There was a good article in the New Republic in ’06, when Obama was fresh, describing Obama’s connection to Alinsky. In all seriousness, Alinsky was his Yoda.
We should look at McCain’s legislative record AND associations. Usually they are related–he legislates for those he associates with (lobbyists).
Doug– the uncapping of payroll taxes as described would a lot of people in a 50%+ federal tax situation. Basically anyone self-employed making 100k+. It’s the one bad idea I think Obama has. I don’t really want to pay over a million bucks into social security over the remainder of my working life. I just don’t. With the cap in place, I’ve already paid over $100k in, and I’m only 37…
I say raise the cap to 100k, then no payroll taxes for 100-250k, then phase it back in. That would still be a substantial tax increase–but it would not be a disincentive to working and making over $100k. Or if there isn’t going to be a cap, lower the rate to more like 5% (10% for self-employed fools like me), which would also constitute a middle-class tax cut.
Seems like at least a phase out would be good; something that’s a relatively light burden on that additional $100k but which captures a number of dollars from huge incomes. I don’t have any fundamental objection to the donut hole you describe, however.
On a related note (salary), I think most of these laws need to have a movable marker in them, based on census.
For example, tax brackets, AGI tax, things like T is talking about, should all be either based on what the poverty level is calculated at or what median income is calculated at.
Laws that should be on the books for years shouldn’t have something as dated as a fixed incoming mark like $50k, $100k, $250k, and so on…
You know what the biggest impediment to uncapping Socialist Isecurity taxes is?
Keeping the charade going that SS is a pension, not a welfare program.
The reason for the cap is that SS is supposed to be a pension system, one that is bare bones and there to provide an income floor for the elderly.
You are supposed to save and have a private pension to also get you through old age in comfort and style.
To really “save” SS, uncapping the tax needs to be combined with capping benefits. It doesn’t help the system if the guy making a million bucks a year also has his benefits increased by a million bucks in the future. So you set up the system so that taxes paid in excess of $100k income don’t increase future benefits.
But if you uncap taxes and make benefits unrelated to what was paid in, SS become welfare, not a pension.
For example, tax brackets, AGI tax, things like T is talking about, should all be either based on what the poverty level is calculated at or what median income is calculated at.
Well, since the 1970s, all these things have been indexed to inflation. So it could be a lot worse.
But I think that you are on to a VERY subtle point: because of growth in incomes beyond inflation, over time people are moving into higher and higher tax brackets. Even if the Bush tax cuts are kept intact, taxes paid will rise with time because of this income/ bracket creep.
It kind of defeats the purpose of progressive taxation if we’re all in the highest tax bracket! Well, I guess that’s one way to get a flat tax.
I thought Social Security WAS welfare…I know I don’t plan on getting anything from it.
It’s a hybrid pension plan, insurance policy, and welfare plan. Your benefits are related to the amount paid into the system, but not strictly. Some people who don’t pay into the system get benefits — for example, children whose parents are killed. Some people get benefits far in excess to what they pay in — those who suffer from a disability.
I suspect we’d regard the plan as successful overall if we took a look at how the elderly were doing prior to its implementation.
I suspect we’d regard the plan as successful overall if we took a look at how the elderly were doing prior to its implementation.
I don’t think that you could separate the effect that SS had on the elderly vs. how much wealthier they are because the nation has become so much wealthier over the same time frame.
And, considering that the elderly are the second wealthiest demograhic, second only to the near-elderly, one has to wonder if they’d be better off had SS never been implemented.
Certainly I would be a lot better off if SS had been replaced with an enhanced 401(k) way back when. I’ve maxed out my 401(k) since I started working. There were years early on there where I could have easily put twice as much in as they let me. Saving 30% of my income tax free when I was a DINK would have been awesome.
Instead, I feel like Jason, that my payroll taxes just went down a rathole, never to be seen again.
Doug, I know that there is an insurance aspect to SS. And it is progressive, so that the poorer make a slightly better return than the richer.
But it has been sold to the middle class as a pension, where your benefits are closely tied to what you paid. I think that efforts to uncap in the past have foundered on this one point. It is an important aspect of the system.
There’s a chicken & egg problem for sure. On the other side, I wonder if our society could have gotten this much richer without the safety net. I tend to think widely distributed wealth tends to encourage more economic activity than concentrated wealth. Social Security played a part in making sure the elderly had some money to spend. A minimal level of support also probably decreases the overall expense of the elderly individual on society: less likely to end up entangled with the legal system, more likely to be able to nip health problems earlier, that sort of thing.
For my part, without social security, I’m fairly sure I would have squandered even more of my resources through my 20s.
I think it makes a fine safety net. The examples of kids who lose a parent is a good one. Also the elderly poor. I think people today could become more convinced that it isn’t a pension, since people are more aware of 401k’s, Roths, etc., and are more used to actively managing their own retirements. If such a paradigm shift occurred so that not everyone expected a payout (for example, I’ve assumed I won’t get any payout because if it’s still solvent, there will probably be means testing), I wouldn’t have a problem with it, if the means of funding it changed.
If it became basically welfare, then I would expect the burden for funding it to not simply fall on those in the $0-93k (I think that’s the cap now) range. Right now, a self-employed person making $100k contributes the same amount of payroll tax as Bill Gates does. For Bill, it’s just a blip. But for the $100k wage earner, it’s a car, or a year of college tuition for their child. Now what would the system look like if everyone paid, say, 2% on all earnings (even capital gains and dividends), with no cap? It would be a very effective stimulus to the economy because it would be a tax cut for most workers. But I bet it would improve the funding picture, too.
Eliminating SS is fine in theory. That is until the working poor get too old and infirm to work. I would rather not have to wade through a sea of homeless elderly on my way to the grocery store, which is what will happen if social security is gone. Security is the key word there. Will you enjoy people being homeless, living under street lamps on your corner, rummaging in your trash cans at night, and begging in front of your office?
Yes, I am a bleeding heart and want to save the world, but social security does more than that – it’s not just security for the people who don’t have the wherewithal to save for themselves, it’s also security for the rest of us who do, who don’t want to live in a world of homeless beggars and constant crime. It IS welfare. It’s welfare for everyone.
So Buzzcut, clear this up for me. “Social Insecurity” is gone. We all save for ourselves. What do YOU do with the MASSES of people who don’t save? Let them roam the streets? Build them a compound? Shoot them all with your arsenal of automatic weapons? Or just let them live in your driveway?
For me, I’d rather pay into a system now that keeps the homeless out of my driveway than have to constantly call the police to get rid of them. Because what will happen if social security is gone is that we will pay that money somewhere else – either in prisons, police force, homeless shelters, HUD, food stamps, etc. It’ll still come out. At least one way makes me feel safer and leaves less old people on the street.
I’m more of a big picture kind of thinker – less concerned with how to keep every nickel buried in my backyard and more concerned with how to keep America beautiful for my children. My vision of “America the Beautiful” does not include masses of homeless on every corner.
Also, while I think everyone should pay into social security whether they want to or not, I think it should be optional whether you receive it. If you don’t need it, I don’t think you should take it.
Amy –
The situation you describe is about when ‘Soylent Green’ becomes a documentary…
The best idea I have read reading this blog is that everyone should pay into SS but at 2%.I hope that idea is thoroughly examined.
My mother has as much income on SS now as she did when my father was working,and that’s quite a positive statement about SS.Of course inflation has diminished returns but she still feels she is ahead. And SS is ‘for sure’ every month. My parents surely wouldn’t have saved anything,if there had been these private accounts republicans have been pushing..We generally ran out of money for the week before pay day.
Now,SS allows her to stay in her home and be independant. She’s 89 and a stalwart conservative republican but I have never heard her say anything bad about SS and medicare. She feels she deserves everything she gets.
I told her SS will not ever go bankrupt ( she watches fox news exclusively).I said the best solution is to do nothing if the other option is cutting benefits in any way.SS failing will mean that our entire government has failed..SS will always be funded no matter how.
GW has shown one thing to Americans: Government funding is never an issue if it’s on the agenda.
I like the 2% idea, but even more, I like the idea of being able to decline it.
What about a tax break equal to what you’re turning down? Not dollar for dollar, but if I’m still earning income at 70, but I’m able to get $300 a month from SS but turn it down, I’d like to think that I could at least not have more SS money taken out at that point.
If they’re wanting to give me money while they’re taking money, how about I turn down their money and they stop taking mine? Seems fair.
Social Security reform as the rapture. Yeah that’s pretty likely.
If you’re really such a “big picture” person, you need to get beyond the “first order effects” of SS policy, and get into the nitty gritty of its unintended consequences.
The payroll tax sucks up 15.5% of people’s earnings. It is an enourmous deadweight loss around the neck of the economy. It creates huge disincentives to get educated, work and save.
Harvard economist Martin Feldstein has a paper from 1995 where he calculated how much bigger the economy would have been had SS been privatized in 1983 (instead of “reformed” by simply jacking up the payroll tax, as was done). He calculated that the economy would have been 1/3 larger in ’95.
So… what would be the best way to privatize SS and get that increased economic growth? Let people take their portion of the payroll tax and invest it in a 401(k). Use the employer portion to keep the current system afloat for those too far along in life to benefit from the 401(k). Make 100% of SS benefits taxable, to better means test the program and make it slightly more affordable. Decrease the COLA by 1% per year, to gradually cut benefits and make the system more affordable. And gradually raise the retirement age.
If it is madatory that you invest your portion of the payroll tax in a 401(k), then we won’t have foolish people who don’t save. And it will do wonders for the savings rate.
In many ways, SS is the easy program to fix. Medicare is the program that is really bankrupting the country, and the one that has very few solutions for. The whole notion of paying for elderly healthcare is going to become untennable when the baby boomers retire.
FICA taxes give elderly opponents something to blame when they’re not enjoying the standard of living in retirement that they thought they’d have when they were Young Republicans.
You see, they couldn’t save enough money because the damn gummint took too much of it.
It’s all about personal responsibility, ya know. Avoiding it, that is.
Maybe if only they could just flame liberals a little better, they’d have a sinecure at a right-wing think tank.
(I hope you guys are enjoying your weather, it’s a god damned 95+ degrees here with high humidity. No wonder so many southerners act like their brains have been cooked.)
Buzz, your plan doesn’t sound half bad. Too bad that’s not what any of the Republicans tout.
What I see from the Republicans is big talk and no policy. “Let’s have people save for themselves!” with no plan to back it up. When I see that, all I see is homeless elderly because just telling people to save won’t work. That was exactly what pissed me off in every political debate during the last presidential election. Every time Shrub was asked about plans for social security, he would say Americans should be in charge of their own retirement savings. Then he would STOP TALKING. There was no PLAN. Nothing available on the websites, NOTHING. All I heard was dead air. Nothing about mandatory savings in 401ks. That was NOT a part of the policy plans during the last election cycle.
That’s what I’ve learned about Republicans – they keep all their plans a secret. The less you know the better. Trust me, go to McCain’s website and compare his Education platform to both Hillary’s and Obama’s. McCain has NO PLAN, just talk about picking your school. No specifics about how that’s going to be accomplished. Just “blah blah, parents should pick schools, blah blah.” Not anything about how children will get to these schools, what parents will do when all the good schools are full and they can’t get their kid into the school they want. Nothing. If you look at every single other Democrat platform, you will see actual, well-written, documented, lengthy plans. McCain doesn’t even MENTION early childhood education or college on his website.
I’m just using Education as an example, but all the planks are the same. That’s precisely the difference between Republicans and Democrats. The Republicans try to win elections by attacking the Democrats. The Democrats try to win by writing up strong policy. The Republicans might have good policies (mostly they don’t) but who would know? They keep it all a secret until after the election when it’s too late to use it against them.
Amy, above, put into words something that is difficult to explain in a few words about why conservatism ( as we know it today) fails. .After ‘the process’ there is no program and no guarantees or no accountability ( unless we count non-profitability as accountability).
To reform SS or Medicare or public education,or Healthcare, theres just one set of actions that fits all. Privatize(funnel everyone’s wealth to the private sector),make sure there are no restraints on private action and then elected government is ordered to walk away. If something goes wrong,blame those who complain and make them examples of why the system as set up is not working( we can’t pay higher minimum wage or it ruins the profitabilty of the investors,etc.).
There is no such concept as ‘curricula’ for schools or ‘care’ in health care.It’s all just ‘process’.Greed and self-interest becomes the only way to succeed and success depends greed coupled with access to the money funneling.
Let’s look to our Constitution,with its checks and balances applying to all sectors, as an example of how we should organize any entity ,otherwise we have selected carte blanche,as we have now.
You think I made that plan up myself? It’s out there, some aspects were in Dubya’s SS reform plan that died on the vine in the first term.
What more can the federal government do in the realm of education? Since they first started meddling in education since 1965, results have gone nowhere but down.
Sadly, I think that Americans just don’t value education. If people put half the effort into their children’s academics that they do into, say, travel baseball, we would have the best education system in the world.
The difference between the US and, say, India or China is that Indian and Chinese parents push their kids to excell. In the US, we push our kids to be slackers.
Hell, Munster just got rid of class rank! The best school district in the state of Indiana just got rid of class rank.
We need a cultural change, not another governmental program. People need to wake the F up and realize that the Chinese and Indians are preparing their next generation to take our livelihoods away.
I find it highly amusing that in your slam against education you misspelled the word excel. I’m not going to get into an education debate with you, since last time you called me a moron. But I will say that I have a lot of thoughts on the topic of education, both as a parent and as an educator, and the Republicans haven’t got a goddamn clue. Take a look at the worthless No Child Left Behind bit of lunacy.
If you think I’m making this up, take a look at McCain’s plan to reform SS… Oh wait, he doesn’t have one! It’s all “Abortions are bad, education sucks! Elect me! Elect me!” Show me where he has in depth policy. Download Obama’s 15 page Health Care plan and tell me how it compares with McCain’s blurb on health care. Maybe he has big plans, but he sure as hell isn’t sharing them – which is exactly what Republicans do. Maybe they have secret meetings where they talk policy, but when they campaign, it’s all “Abortions are bad! Guns are good! Get the fucking queers out of my face!”
But anyone, like I said before, if you are a huge Bush fan, McCain is your man. Do you wear your ‘I voted for W’ shirt with pride?
I find it highly amusing that in your slam against education you misspelled the word excel.
Hey, I never claimed to be anything more than I am: a public school graduate. I can’t spell. But I can put condoms on banannas like nobody’s business.
I’m not going to get into an education debate with you, since last time you called me a moron.
Prove it. I don’t think I did.
There is no denying that education majors are on the low end of the bell curve for college graduates as far as test scores go. But that hardly makes them morons.
Just not as intelligent as engineers, doctors, lawyers, and other people with college degrees.