Craig has an excellent post up about what lies ahead in the race between McCain and Obama. First will be experience. But that probably won’t play so well since the kind of experience we’ve seen lately from McCain, Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld et. al. hasn’t lead us to good places.
As for the second:
Obama is quite new. The public doesn’t know him very well. That is why 10-13% of Americans believe he is secretly a Muslim. His patriotism will continue to be questioned. There will be whisperings about whether or not he understands “real Americansâ€. It will be noted that he is in fact a Christian, but questions will be raised as to whether or not he is the “right kind†of Christian. I for one cannot remember any presidential election in which the undergraduate thesis of a candidate’s wife was under scrutiny, but that is exactly what has happened this year. The1985 senior thesis of Michelle Obama was a regular topic of discussion on the Sean Hannity radio show. It should be noted that Hannity also misquoted the document in order to attribute words to Michelle Obama that were not her own.
“He’s not like us” will be the beat of the drum.
Also worth reading this morning, Ruth Holladay points us to a New York Times article entitled “Calm in the Swirl of History”:
A reporter reads aloud from the novelist Darryl Pinckney’s essay in The New York Review of Books. Mr. Obama, the novelist writes, “comes across as someone who stored away for future consideration practically everything that was ever said to him, and who had a talent for watchfulness, part of the extraordinary armor he developed at an early age.â€
Mr. Obama nods. That’s intriguing. But he prefers his own riff, which not incidentally trains the eye not on him but on his crowds. “I love when I’m shaking hands on a rope line andâ€â€” he mimes the motion, hand over hand — “I see little old white ladies and big burly black guys and Latino girls and all their hands are entwining. They’re feeding on each other as much as on me.”
He shrugs; it’s that distancing eye of the author.
“It’s like I’m just the excuse.â€
I have an education degree, and yet I beat Doug on the IQ test last time. (Not by a landslide or anything…) Probably I wouldn’t do as well on the LSATs, but that doesn’t mean I deserve to be called names or have my career choice discredited, even if I have left the field.
I don’t suppose your extensive education research indicates any trending in terms of the number of teachers versus the number of lawyers, engineers, etc? Do you realize that admittance into those “smarter” programs is limited to keep it “prestigious” while the teacher education programs admits many times more candidates? (And yet there’s STILL a teacher shortage.)
Of course, you are a Republican so I know your answer to the education crisis. Punish schools and teachers and try to employ engineers and mathematicians to teach school. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again – just because you get an advanced degree does NOT mean you’ll be able to teach that material to others. It takes more than the ability to pass a test to be a good teacher.
I have seen teachers that cling to their union for a dependable paycheck without putting much effort in. However, those people are the minority.
Most teachers I have seen REALLY want to do their job, and do it well. To me, there are two (primary) issues with public education:
1. The way we pay for it is beyond stupid. Show me someone that can explain that the way we divide up money in Indiana so I can call them a liar. Whatever money goes to a school should be per-child, and WITHOUT restrictions. If Avon wants to blow their $$ on football, but Muncie wants to spend it on teacher’s pay, fine. State, Federal, and local money should be able to be used for whatever the local school feels will be best.
However, once we remove the BS tape on the money, we should allow anyone (private business or religious) to be paid the same per-student rate.
2. Let the teachers decide on and design the tests, then test in the spring. Fall testing is one of the dumbest things I have ever heard of. Once we have a proper test and timing, the school administration should be held accountable for the performance of the school. Reducing money shouldn’t be the answer, but I do not agree with just allowing the fox to guard the henhouse.
Probably I wouldn’t do as well on the LSATs, but that doesn’t mean I deserve to be called names or have my career choice discredited, even if I have left the field.
And who did that?
The LSAT is pretty heavily correlated with other standardized tests. I bet you would score about as well as your IQ score. You would give Doug a run for his money, I’m sure.
I do think that one of the problems in the education field is that pedagogy is emphasized more than mastery of the subject.
BTW, engineering school is as open as education schools are. There is no limit to the number of students admitted like there is at medical schools.
And unlike medicine, law, or education, there is no post graduation exam or licensing required.
It is as wideopen a profession as it could possibly be.
The only thing that limits the number of engineers is the difficulty of the curriculum.
I think there has to be some sort of funding allowance for fixed costs.
I thought engineers in Indiana had to pass the Fundamentals of Engineering (F.E.) exam upon completion of coursework, and the Professional Engineering (P.E.) exam after a certain period of time. Is that not true?
It is not true. There is no requrement to pass the FE or become a PE.
What do you mean by funding allowance for fixed costs? They would still be able to pay for fixed costs through the cash they get.
If you’re talking about granting a school millions to build a new building, then what I’m saying it instead of that, take all the different ways you pay for schools, divide by students, and pay it all out evenly. If a school is going to be building something soon, they can start saving for it. If they must build it now, they can get a loan and pay it off with their cash that comes in.
I’m talking about the fact that there are certain fixed costs that don’t go up or down based on how many students you’re servicing. If you have a building that services 500 students and have maintenance, loans, and whatever else; those costs don’t necessarily go down if your population falls to 400 students for some reason.
There should be per student funding for those expenses that rise and fall based on the number of students at a school. Money should be allocated in different ways for those expenses that don’t rise and fall based on the number of students.
How about we get rid of government funding of schools. Instead, we give everybody a $5000 tax credit per kid to pay for school…
Sorry, McCain’s health care proposal has infected every part of my brain, and I’m applying it to every problem that comes my way!
Why?
To me, part of the problem is that schools are designed without throught to ongoing costs.
If a school puts in a floor that needs less work to maintain, or windows that open to allow A/C to be turned off on mild days, it gets no credit for this. In turn, schools will go with cheaper options to build that cost more in the long run.
There should be per student funding for those expenses that rise and fall based on the number of students at a school. Money should be allocated in different ways for those expenses that don’t rise and fall based on the number of students.
100% disagree.
Look, one reason that Gary spends $14k per pupil is because of depopulation. They have a school system set up to cater to a population of half a million, but are less than half that now. And you think that they should be rewarded for not acknowledging the reality that they need to downsize?
Gary has 5 high schools, yet their total high school population is less than any of the single, large suburban high schools in Lake County.
I’m no fan of those large high schools, but Gary needs to face facts, close some schools and fire some teachers.
Um, you did. In an old post that is somewhere in Doug’s archives when you slammed public school teachers.
Doug is freakishly good at multiple choice, I’m pretty sure I wouldn’t score in the 95th percentile like he did. But IQ tests are less general knowledge and more relations (spacial, logical sequencing, etc.) and that kind of stuff I can handle.
100% disagree. One doesn’t have to be a “master” of the subject to be a great teacher. They just need the ability and desire to learn it. Having the drive to be a good teacher trumps “mastery” of the subject any day. If I don’t know what needs to be taught, I can sure as hell learn it. If I don’t have the drive to excel in my field, knowing everything about it isn’t going to make me a great teacher.