This story, written by Seth Slabaugh, for the Muncie Star Press entitled Barbers, cosmetologists opposing deregulation is a good illustration of why once the legislature licenses an occupation, the process is unlikely ever to be reversed.
Rep. Wolkins, the person who describes himself as the “small-government” person, is pretty openly throwing his arms up and isn’t going to push for his HB 1006 which would deregulate barbers, cosmetologists, hearing aid dealers, and security guards. The act of licensure creates a self-preserving constituency, and the counter-interest in the general public is much more diffuse. So, when the deregulation bill comes up; you have a very motivated group fighting. The general public who might experience lower costs (perhaps significant in the aggregate but not to any given individual) and potential practitioners who might enter into the occupation if the barriers were reduced are spread out and have an interest that is more abstract.
I expect Rep. Wolkins is getting lobbyist bending his ear, creating the specter of streets filled with madmen posing as professionals, splashing caustic chemicals all about and plying the population with disease. That’s sort of been the tone on my previous blog post. Though, as one commenter from Great Britain noted, they seem to be working through the horrors without a similar licensure scheme.
Don’t get me wrong. I’m one of the members of the general public with nothing but an abstract interest in the case. I have little hair and get it cut at home by my wife with a set of clippers. I’m not even sure it’s good policy to de-regulate these professions. But, the dynamics of the response leave me convinced that good policy has little to do with the outcome. The outcome is determined because those with a vested interest are organized and those with a more indirect interest are not. The people who sell the requisite educational credit hours and the people who benefit from restricted competition will line up to persuade the legislator; and the legislator will gain little to nothing but grief by opposing them in favor of those who are disorganized. That’s not just an issue in licensure situations, by the way.