Carrie Ritchie, writing for the Indianapolis Star, has an article entitled Jury finds Indiana Secretary of State Charlie White guilty on 6 of 7 felony charges. (Ritchie, by the way, did a phenomenal job reporting on the trial as it happened via Twitter. Really a great mix of the old media using the new media, in my ever so humble opinion.)
White was convicted of three counts of voter fraud, two counts of perjury, and one count of theft. He was acquitted of committing fraud on a financial institution. Basically, he lied about his residence and registered to vote at a place where he wasn’t living. He did so because he had moved out of the precinct where he had been elected to the Fishers Town Council and, had he been honest about where he lived, would have no longer been eligible to continue serving and get a paycheck. He claimed he was living in his ex-wife’s basement when, in reality, it appears he was living with his fiance in the town home they’d bought. One of the most telling pieces of evidence Ritchie tweeted about was that cell phone towers near the town home picked up something like 400 (or maybe it was 600) calls from White’s cell phone after business hours versus only something like 60 from the tower near his ex-wife’s home.
I feel a little bad for White, not because I believe he made some kind of honest mistake or because I feel like the jury got the facts wrong. Rather, at some level, voter registration laws don’t seem like “real” laws. I know they are, and I know we don’t get to pick and choose our laws, but at a gut level, the voter registration requirements feel like just so much bureaucratic paperwork.
For the state, the bigger question is for the office of Secretary of State. The suit before the Recount Commission resulted in a reviewing trial court determining that White was not a properly registered voter at the time of the election and, therefore, was never an eligible candidate. (As a matter of fact, this jury verdict helps support that determination — though, I’m not brushed up enough on my collateral estoppel rules to recall whether this criminal jury verdict could be used at some point in the legal proceedings to bolster the claim in that civil matter). The upshot of that Recount case is that White was never an eligible candidate and, therefore, the eligible candidate that received the most votes gets the job — Vop Osili (Democrat). The felony conviction, on the other hand, results in an officeholder’s removal from office; with a replacement appointed by the Governor (Republican).
Political parties being what they are; the matter of whether the Governor’s appointment as replacement or Vop Osili as highest eligible vote recipient gets to keep the job will be litigated three ways from Sunday. Conceptually, I’m pretty firm on the idea that this is Osili’s. Someone could run me through the law to show me why I’m wrong; but right now I’m fairly certain that White’s election was void ab initio. He was never the valid winner because he never was an eligible candidate. As such, the later conviction is of someone who never legally held the office in the first place. Under IC 3-12-11-25, Vop Osili was entitled to a certificate of election.
[W]henever the [recount] commission makes a final determination under section 18 of this chapter that the candidate who is subject to a contest proceeding is not eligible to serve in the office to which the candidate is nominated or elected, the candidate who received the second highest number of votes for the office is entitled to a certificate of nomination or certificate of election even though a certificate may have been issued to another candidate upon the tabulation of the votes.
Under that statute, Osili was entitled to a certificate of election. Just as a thief can’t pass legal title to property to someone else; White’s actions can’t serve as the basis for conveying the office to someone else. The property rights still belong to the original owner; and the right to the office, by virtue of the certificate of election, still belongs to the eligible candidate that received the most votes. Even if I’m correct about that, I wouldn’t be surprised if the Governor’s replacement is allowed to occupy the office through the 2012 elections which could, potentially have consequences for those elections.