Brian Howey has a column suggesting that Mike Pence shouldn’t be measuring for drapes in the Governor’s office quite this early.
Sure, Pence has deep pocketed donors, a lot of name recognition, and the ability to talk; not to mention that Hoosiers are tribally more inclined to identify with Republicans these days. So, you can understand if he’d take things for granted and not feel the need to bother telling Hoosiers what he’d do if he’s chosen for the job. Just let him ascend to the pulpit office already.
And, Howey, acknowledges (as do I) that Pence has to be regarded as the favorite, he sets out a few challenges Pence has:
1. Pence is a Congressman, and Congress is about as popular as the plague right now. It’s less popular than Nixon during Watergate.
2. Pence might get caught up in either evangelical dislike of Mitt Romney or moderates distaste for Santorum.
3. Pence might be very unpopular with women given his attacks on Planned Parenthood – an issue which has suddenly become much more relevant with things like Bob Morris’ Girl Scout Communist, tactical arm of Planned Parenthood ravings or Santorum’s sugar daddy aspirin between the knees “joke” or Rush Limbaugh’s slut shaming of the student who wanted to testify about the importance of contraception.
4. Pence’s silence about the having or not having an agenda when he becomes Governor; other than some vague allusion to jobs. “Stay the course” on Daniels’ jobs agenda might be less viable to the extent that Daniels’ jobs record turns out to be illusory.
5. Pence’s tendency toward theocracy. Having one’s religion inform one’s policy decisions is one thing – it’s inevitable, and it’s not a bad thing. Having one’s perceived religious duties trump one’s civic duties is more troublesome in a public servant. And that’s the persona Pence has chosen to create for himself. If that’s also the reality of the man, so much the worse. Charlatans are less troublesome for a civic society than True Believers.
Finally, of course, his challenger is legitimate. I’m hard pressed to think of a state Democrat who is more viable than John Gregg. He was a fairly successful Speaker of the House, able to work pretty well with a Republican Senate from 1996 – 2003. And the man is a charismatic speaker. At LSA, we had closed circuit audio from the Floor of the House piped into the office. He was entertaining to listen to — has a folksy charm about him. I’m guessing he won’t be prone to the type of off-putting campaign rhetoric as Jill Long Thompson, such as her frequent reminder that she has a PhD. Gregg will be much better at connecting with the Hoosier Everyman.
That said, Gregg has to be regarded as the underdog. Pence has the advantage. But, if he fails to simply take the office by acclamation and has to reveal who he is and what he intends to do, I think he’ll start to struggle. In Congress, he’s been allowed to talk in generalities and not do anything specific for the last decade.