SB 15 doesn’t do much of substance but does require a study on the brain injury services offered in Indiana, including: any deficiencies in the provision of brain injury services in Indiana; how to implement additional brain injury services and neurobehavioral rehabilitation programs in Indiana; development of a licensure category for neurobehavioral rehabilitation facilities and the criteria to be included for the license; assessment of whether incentives are needed to encourage the provision of brain injury services and neurobehavioral services in Indiana; determination of the adequate reimbursement under the Medicaid program for brain injury and neurobehavioral services; and determination of whether funds from the Medicaid health facility closure and conversion fund could be used to assist qualified service providers in opening a neurobehavioral rehabilitation facility or to enhance reimbursement for brain injury or neurobehavioral services in Indiana.
SB 1: Confusing and Will Likely Get Someone Killed
SB 1 is the defend your home against tyranny bill. Sounds great when you put it like that. “Look at me! I’m George Washington. Take that King George! Blam! Blam!”
But, really what we’re talking about is a lot of grey areas where citizens pissed off about government action – even legal government action – will selectively perceive tyranny when law enforcement is acting legally or in a way that can be remedied after the fact unless someone gets hurt. Used to be, the General Assembly sent the message that you probably ought to wait and sort things out later instead of shooting first. Now, they offer up a word salad that doesn’t do anyone any favors.
The first sign of danger is that the General Assembly felt it necessary to offer a “purpose” section. Good legislation is like a good joke. If you have to explain it first, you’re doing it wrong.
Then, we get three new subsections:
(i) A person is justified in using reasonable force against a public servant if the person reasonably believes the force is necessary to:
(1) protect the person or a third person from what the person reasonably believes to be the imminent use of unlawful force;
(2) prevent or terminate the public servant’s unlawful entry of or attack on the person’s dwelling, curtilage, or occupied motor vehicle; or
(3) prevent or terminate the public servant’s unlawful trespass on or criminal interference with property lawfully in the person’s possession, lawfully in possession of a member of the person’s immediate family, or belonging to a person whose property the person has authority to protect.
(j) Notwithstanding subsection (i), a person is not justified in using force against a public servant if:
(1) the person is committing or is escaping after the commission of a crime;
(2) the person provokes action by the public servant with intent to cause bodily injury to the public servant;
(3) the person has entered into combat with the public servant or is the initial aggressor, unless the person withdraws from the encounter and communicates to the public servant the intent to do so and the public servant nevertheless continues
or threatens to continue unlawful action; or
(4) the person reasonably believes the public servant is:
(A) acting lawfully; or
(B) engaged in the lawful execution of the public servant’s official duties.
(k) A person is not justified in using deadly force against a public servant whom the person knows or reasonably should know is a public servant unless:
(1) the person reasonably believes that the public servant is:
(A) acting unlawfully; or
(B) not engaged in the execution of the public servant’s official duties; and
(2) the force is reasonably necessary to prevent serious bodily injury to the person or a third person.
So, if you got evicted from your property but don’t believe the court proceedings were proper (perhaps you are a sovereign citizen), then you would seemingly be able to use force, but maybe not deadly force, against the Sheriff enforcing the writ under subsection (i). A person can use force if the person “reasonably” believes the force is necessary to prevent the public servant’s unlawful interference with the person’s property. When does a person’s belief become unreasonable? I have no idea.
Spring Break 2012
I’m on Spring Break with the family. Vacations are always a bit of an act of faith that the increased productivity of a rested brain will outweigh the pile of work that builds up over the course of your time off. I tend to be reluctant to take a lot of time off for that purpose, but almost always when I do, I end up on the positive side of the ledger.
And, more importantly, spending time with the family. Much gets made over quality time, but quantity time is important. A lot of bonding takes place over the course of a million minor interactions you’d never schedule for but which are crucial nonetheless.
This year, we’re once again paying tribute to the Florida theme parks; Universal versus last year’s Disney. I’m a bigger fan of Universal, turns out. The organization is a little more haphazard and the employees a little rougher around the edges; but the themes of Universal – Harry Potter, Marvel Comics, etc. – are more appealing to me.
We got down here by driving again. For me, the best way to travel is to drive through the night. I know that’s not for everyone; but, podcasts have revolutionized the game. Whereas in years past the graveyard hours were characterized by a struggle to stay awake during the frequent commercial breaks on AM radio – during the Art Bell show if I was lucky; now, I can just load up on Nerdist podcasts and Dan Carlin’s Hardcore history: stuff that engages me with no commercial breaks. Suddenly, once the family has dozed off, we’re 600 miles down the road before the sun comes up. Leave at 4 p.m., arrive in Kissimme at 10 a.m. with a couple of meal stops in between.
The weather was a little rainy on Saturday and Sunday, but since then, bright and sunny. Beach day at St. Pete today.
Anyway, talk about your own family vacation adventures/nightmares or, open thread!
Gay License Plate Obsession
Not content to just let it rest this short session — reserved, I’ve heard it said, for “emergency” issues — anti-gay legislators had signaled that they’d let the Indiana Youth Group license plate matter rest. Despite that, there were rumblings that they’d try to jam it into an end of session conference committee despite the fact the provision hadn’t passed either house on the first go round.
Presumably spurred on by their masters at the American Family Association of Indiana and Advance America of Indiana, it looks as if these legislators are apparently urging the State of Indiana to subject the group’s contract to special scrutiny based on the content of their speech and their sexual orientation.
Mary Beth Schneider reports:
While legislative leaders did not officially declare the effort to pass a bill dead, Senate President Pro Tempore David Long said another “solution” had been found: Voiding the Indiana Youth Group plate.
Long said he believed the Indiana Youth Group had violated its state contract and that it should be cancelled.
“There’s a contract clause apparently which I just saw today which apparently says you cannot remarket those for value and they’re doing that clearly on their internet site,” Long said. “And if they are it says you ‘shall’ terminate the contract.”
Apparently they gave out a couple of low numbered plates to some donors; something the BMV has traditionally allowed other groups to do.
I love the smell of an equal protection lawsuit in the morning. Smells like victory.
Studying Unbelief
I flatter myself as having a fairly good knack for empathy, the ability to emotionally identify with others. That’s not to say I’m necessarily motivated to act on that understanding. My tendency toward sympathy is more limited. However, I’ve notice that, in matters of faith, my capacity for empathy is diminishing (that doesn’t mean my sympathy toward believers is necessarily moving one way or another). I just have a hard time getting into a believer’s head and seeing the subject of religion and God from their perspective. For my part, the supernatural beliefs of humanity over the millenia have been so varied and at odds, I don’t grok the mind that is so certain any of them are right – let alone one of them in particular – that one ought to conform their life’s behavior to that belief.
Ed Brayton has a blog post entitled Scholars Study Secularism. Apparently, there may be cognitive differences between the minds of believers and unbelievers.
Boston University’s Catherine Caldwell-Harris is researching the differences between the secular and religious minds. “Humans have two cognitive styles,” the psychologist says. “One type finds deeper meaning in everything; even bad weather can be framed as fate. The other type is neurologically predisposed to be skeptical, and they don’t put much weight in beliefs and agency detection.”
Caldwell-Harris is currently testing her hypothesis through simple experiments. Test subjects watch a film in which triangles move about. One group experiences the film as a humanized drama, in which the larger triangles are attacking the smaller ones. The other group describes the scene mechanically, simply stating the manner in which the geometric shapes are moving. Those who do not anthropomorphize the triangles, she suspects, are unlikely to ascribe much importance to beliefs. “There have always been two cognitive comfort zones,” she says, “but skeptics used to keep quiet in order to stay out of trouble.”
That last bit about keeping quiet struck me as an interesting line. I think the cultural status quo remains in place by socially isolating views outside of the mainstream. The weakness of those non-conforming views is probably out of proportion to its actual prevalence. The Internet is probably changing that; where holders of even the most marginal viewpoints can find a like minded community. Anyway, defined broadly enough, nonbelievers appear to be a non-trivial segment of the population:
But the most significant target of Kosmin’s research is the consumer group most likely to shy away from such commercial products: secularists. “The non-religious, or Nones, hold the fastest-growing world view in the market,” says Kosmin. “In the past 20 years, their numbers in the United States have doubled to 15 percent.”
. . .
This umbrella [of non-believers] covers various groups including atheists, agnostics and humanists, as well as those who are simply indifferent to religion.Secularists make up some 15 percent of the global population, or about 1 billion people. As a group, this puts them third in size behind Christians (2.3 billion) and Muslims (1.6 billion).
One of the fun parts, they tend to know more about the God they don’t believe in than believers. “Even when the higher education levels of the unreligious were factored out, they proved to be better informed in matters of faith, followed by Jewish and Mormon believers.”
This kind of thing will do nothing to rest the minds of those who feel like the country is going to hell because of our decadent culture.
HB 1283 – Includes “State Rifle”
Just caught wind of HB 1283 from Sheila Kennedy.
She cites news reports of the wide vote margin on the bill and wonders about the priorities of the General Assembly. I don’t know what news reports she saw, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they gave an incomplete account of the bill – focusing primarily or exclusively on the “state rifle” issue.
Looks like this bill was initially concerned with libraries and historic records, making changes to the membership of the library and historical board and revising some of the board’s duties and procedures.
It also changed the historical bureau’s duties with respect to commemorative medallions, specifies certain historical markers as property of the state, added “electronic media” to the definition of public record in the public records law, required the public records commission to coordinate the use of scanning equipment in state government, requires a county commission on public records to implement local government retention schedules, removed the policy that public libraries provide free library services for all individuals, Repealed the law allowing certain township trustees to pay the cost of a library card for certain residents, and made changes to the Class 1 and 2 library law.
Apparently the gun thing didn’t get added until the Senate Committee on Local Government took a look at it. They added a chapter that read:
Sec. 1. The “Grouseland Rifle” made by Colonel John Small of Vincennes, Indiana, between 1803 and 1812 is designated the official rifle of the state of Indiana.
Sec. 2. Any:
(1) duplication or reproduction; or
(2) sale of any duplication or reproduction;
of the “Grouseland Rifle” must be authorized by the Grouseland Foundation of Vincennes, Indiana.
A little historical background: Grouseland was apparently a territorial governor’s mansion in Vincennes, completed in 1804 and named by William Henry Harrison.
According to a Lewis and Clark site:
John Small, who had settled in Vincennes about 1780, had served with William Clark’s older brother, the famous George Rogers Clark, which established his connection with the Clark family. In addition to being a gunsmith, Small was the first sheriff of Vincennes. He served in the first Indiana Territory Legislature, and was a Colonel in the Indiana Militia. He died in 1823.
The site speculates that the Small rifle was with William Clark on his expedition with Meriwether Lewis.
Anyway, while this sort of nonsense isn’t exactly the “emergency” stuff of a short session, I can’t get too indignant about it. If we’re going to have a “state rifle,” this seems like a good one. But I have to wonder how long until we descend into, say, a state paperclip or a state shaving cream.
Mourdock Still Wrong on Chrysler
I’m not sure it’s anything more than he said in his order at the time of the Chrysler bankruptcy, but the Chrysler bankruptcy judge, now retired, spoke with ABC News.
He reiterated that there was no other funding for Chrysler. It was either the government’s deal or liquidate. Mourdock had no basis for spending $2 million in what looked like a politically motivated legal challenge. Secured creditors got more out of the government deal than they would have out of the only other available deal, liquidation. Mourdock’s challenge, in effect, was demanding that Indiana and secured creditors get less so that auto worker pensions and other unsecured creditors would get nothing.
Anyway, the judge:
[Chrysler] could not have survived without taxpayer money. “The record before the Court was clear that there were no other sources of lending,” said Arthur J. Gonzalez, who served as chief judge of the U.S. bankruptcy court for the Southern District of New York.
. . .
“One thing is clear, without government support in one fashion or another, there were no sources of funding.” Gonzalez, now a law professor at New York University, said Chrysler — then the weakest of the Big 3 automakers — did not have the ability to secure financing on its own and “it was not generating sufficient cash to operate without an outside source of financing.”
. . .
The former chief judge also denied that the speedy bankruptcy hearing somehow prevented private investors from stepping up, pointing out that the government and Chrysler’s creditors had been seeking a solution for 18 months, to no avail.“The notion that the speed of the process may have missed a potential buyer has no basis in the record,” he said.
SB 18 – Duty to Support a Child
Senator Steele’s SB 18 concerning one’s duty to support a child is in conference committee.
The bill reduces the obligation from when the child is 21 to when the child is 19. It provides a mechanism for a child to petition for support for educational needs until the child is 19 (or 21 if the support order went into effect prior to this legislation.) To me the drafting is unclear – I’m not sure if the intent is to exclude education from the duty of support or to say that the end of the duty to support does not end the duty to provide for educational needs.
Doubling Down on the Slut-Shaming
John Cole has a good analysis on the lies Rush Limbaugh had to tell before he could conclude that Sandra Fluke was a slut and a prostitute who should provide sex videos for the enjoyment of Rush and his audience.
1. Ms. Fluke was testifying about her sex life. No, she discusses a variety of reasons women might need contraceptives; prominently discussing the health needs of a friend of hers.
2. Birth control expenses were contingent on the amount of sex Ms. Fluke was having. This betrays a startling ignorance. Birth control pills have the same dosage whether you’re a virgin managing menorrhagia or Lisa Sparks having sex with 919 men in a day.
3. She wants taxpayers to pay for her birth control. In fact, the issue is about whether an individual’s insurance policy has to cover contraception.
4. Ms. Fluke wants to be paid to have sex. A repugnant spin-off of #3. Again, no, she wants an individual’s insurance policy to cover contraception.
5. This was an unfortunate word choice. No. Limbaugh spent three days hurling venom at a college student who wanted to testify about the need for women to have insurance coverage for their reproductive health.
Which brings us to Warner Todd Huston at Hoosier Access. He looks at all this and concludes, it’s hard to argue with Rush. What else do you call such a woman? [His broader point was that we should boycott Carbonite for boycotting Rush because liberal talk show host Ed Schultz called conservative talk show host Laura Ingraham a right-wing talk slut; and Carbonite didn’t boycott Schultz.]
I used to think left-wing feminist types were hyper-sensitive about seeing patriarchal slut shaming everywhere. I probably owe them an apology. Females having sex for enjoyment is apparently intolerable to more people than I thought; so intolerable, apparently, it’s acceptable that some women endure medical problems if necessary to limit other women from having sex for enjoyment.
“This is just about religious freedom.” “This is just about the proper role of government in the health care market.” No, this is about a lot of things. Judging from the commentary of America’s highest paid and most widely heard conservative commentator and his acolytes; a real problem with female sexuality is one of them.
Hoosiers Beat Boilermakers on Senior Night
Just so you know where I’m coming from, I was raised in a house where we had a hat on display that read, “The Lord is my shepherd, but Bobby Knight is my coach.”
What a turn around for IU’s five seniors: Verdell Jones, Tom Pritchard, Matt Roth, Daniel Moore, and Kory Barnett. They capped off a regular season by sweeping Purdue for the first time since 2005 – 2006, and made up for three years of futility. After three losing seasons, they finished this regular one at 24-7; beating teams ranked #1, #2, and #5 along the way.
Some commenter mentioned that the time in the wilderness really makes Hoosier fans appreciate being relevant again. Probably true. And, now it’s time for the Big 10 tournament – which could justifiably be its own region of an NCAA bracket all by itself. Then, at long last, back to the NCAA tournament itself. Glad to have some excitement in March again.
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 157
- 158
- 159
- 160
- 161
- …
- 690
- Next Page »