Tonight all three remaining candidates gave speeches. Quite a study in contrasts. McCain gave a subdued speech in New Orleans with no people in the background and tepid reaction from the crowd. Clinton spoke to a warm crowd in New York City which was rather vague as to her intentions. Obama unleashed a corker to a wildly enthusiastic crowd in Minneapolis.
Obama’s speech was complimentary to Sen. Clinton but he claimed victory in no uncertain terms. He laid down challenges to McCain. The whole speech was very engaging, but his close really got to me. He recounted various eras in American history where our predecessors rose to the occasion before telling the crowd that in years to come we would look back at this as the moment when we got America back on course, among other things, “when we began to care for the sick” and “when the seas stopped rising and the earth began to heal.”
On to November.
Ah, here was the close:
The journey will be difficult. The road will be long. I face this challenge with profound humility, and knowledge of my own limitations. But I also face it with limitless faith in the capacity of the American people. Because if we are willing to work for it, and fight for it, and believe in it, then I am absolutely certain that generations from now, we will be able to look back and tell our children that this was the moment when we began to provide care for the sick and good jobs to the jobless; this was the moment when the rise of the oceans began to slow and our planet began to heal; this was the moment when we ended a war and secured our nation and restored our image as the last, best hope on Earth. This was the moment – this was the time – when we came together to remake this great nation so that it may always reflect our very best selves, and our highest ideals. Thank you, God Bless you, and may God Bless the United States of America.
Poor John McCain! He is a lousy reader off Teleprompters. His forced grins and grimaces were terrible — his staff must be despairing at his gawdawful performance tonight.
What will be striking is the amazement overseas,almost everywhere ,that a black man could be a nominated candidate for president of the United States.If Obama should become president in November,it would revolutionize the world view of our longstanding racial strife ,and set us a new postive tone for american race relations.America has changed.
I’m most familiar with Germany and France where I have spent quite a bit of time,and in both countries there are still periodic current events reporting from black areas of the United states,rural and in big cities, pointing out how much different black life is than white life in the USA,and that blacks ,still today, are consigned to all black areas.This kind of reporting would be brushed off by many in the USA as ‘ ‘liberal biais’ so we never have any national consensus to deal with the issues raised, but seen in Europe as just honest, unbiaised reporting. To be fair ,these reportages also examine poor rural white areas,probably with the intent to point out how our economic system has failed with all these ‘forgotten people’.
Obama as president, just in itself, will do more to spread goodwill for USA than any new foreign policy initiatives.
And the postive effect of Obama being a confirmed enlightened Christian cannot be underestimated.Another obssession in Europe is examining our American heritage of Puritan religious values,and as many view it, which today are manifested in conservative religion and battles against science,also tacitly justifying race separation.
I apologize for being so ‘pro-Obama’.I can’t help myself.His candidacy and nomination victory are just amazing,when we ponder it all.
Yeah, I get the feeling that I’m way too excited about his candidacy for him to ever get elected. I’ve been kicked in the teeth electorally far too many times.
Well, congratulations to Senator Obama. I have been a Clinton supporter but look forward to voting for Obama in November.
A sign of things to come-
Last night John McCain had 1,000 show up to listen to him speak.
Obama had 30,000.
Last time Democrats were this excited about a candidate, Jimmy Carter was elected President of the United States. Like him, or not, his Presidency made the election of Ronald Reagan a landslide win, just four years later.
Just a little reminder that one should probably temper their euphoria with the realization that nobody who runs for President is perfect. And, that sometimes, “change” provokes an unequal, and opposite, reaction.
I’m sorry, Democrats were excited about the candidacy of Jimmy Carter? He was widely viewed as too conservative for the party (of ’76, that is), and as having won the nomination by superior campaign strategy (paying attention to Iowa, e.g., which had previously been viewed as the church social it really is) and by then-cutting-edge image management. He sandbagged Mo Udall as a racist (because Udall was a Mormon, though he’d in fact quit the church over its exclusion of blacks and it was Carter who had questionable racial acts in his past). Finally, he inspired an Anybody But Carter movement that almost persuaded Ted Kennedy to run, and did result in Frank Church and Jerry Brown entering late primaries in an effort to thwart him. And the Democratic-controlled Congress cut him off at the knees once in office.
As for Reagan, that “landslide” of 1980 was in the Electoral College only. Of all the Presidential landslides of the modern era (FDR four times, Eisenhower twice, LBJ, Nixon in ’72, and Reagan twice) his is the only one achieved with less than 51% of the popular vote. In fact we might exclude the last two of FDR’s, which were still sweeping electoral victories achieved with 54 and 53 percent of the vote, respectively. There may be lots of good reasons to temper one’s enthusiasms (in fact, I’ve never heard a good reason not to, at least where politics is concerned), but the idea that Jimmy Carter is some paragon of busted excitement isn’t one of ’em.
Honestly, the thing I fear most about Obama’s chances at being president is the chance of him getting killed.
Leaving out the racist looney, it just seems that dreamers are often killed for their dreams. MLK, JFK, Robert Kennedy, etc…
I really pray that isn’t the case.
DR,
Well, you do make good points. Still, Carter worked the southern charm almost as well as Bill Clinton would later on.
As far as the actual election, you seem to be taking the Hillary Clinton point of view here. Contrary to whatever else you might say or prefer, it is the Electoral College, and nothing else that matters. In that, Reagan whupped up on the incumbent’s butt.
He won a solid electoral victory, no question. But performance in the electoral college isn’t nearly as indicative of the country’s negative reaction to Carter as the popular vote totals. And I believe your reference to a landslide victory by Reagan was as evidence that the country didn’t like Carter’s performance very well.
That McCain speech was painful! The annoyed talkng style of Andy Rooney combined with the grating laugh of Butthead is not a winning combination. Add in frequent misreadings of the teleprompter, the grimacing, and a crowd that didn’t seem to know when the applause lines were happening, and you’ve got a trainwreck. For good measure, they picked a location where he could pronounce the city’s name like an outsider would (New OR-lee-ins).
Or was the laugh more Bevis than Butthead?
It’s spelled Beavis. Get it right.
Yes, the laugh was Beavis, not Butthead.
If reading off a teleprompter is your only criteria for President, Obama is going to win hands down. No question.
I think that you’ll agree that both Kerry and Dukakis read off teleprompters better than their opponents.
One thing we remember about Carter was that he was described as a ‘born again Christian’.At the time, people of national prominence werent labeled that way, and most of us didn’t what ‘born again’ meant..I figured out back in late 70s that it must mean a Southern Baptist with a liberal social conscience,but that definition didn’t endure long.
My point is this. Reagan came in at around 51% of the popular vote to Carter’s 42%. Plus, that is counting a 3rd party candidate from the conservative side of the fence winning a respectable 7% of the popular vote.
That is the fourth best “repudiation” election margin since 1912 (“repudiation” meaning an election where the incumbent party was turned out for contentious policies).
In ascending order, the others were repudiations over income tax and the judiciary (1912 at 14%), the Great Depression (1932 at 18%), and the domestic and international aftermath to the Great War (1920 at 27%). That says something, I’m thinking.
In fact, since 1960 there have only been five elections with similar (or greater) margins of victory, three being incumbent re-elections (including Reagan’s), and Clinton’s facing a split in the other side (between Perot and Dole), not on his own side. I would have taken that argument back to 1912, but FDR kinda skews the curve a little. That says something, too.
Keep in mind as well that Democrats outnumbered Republicans by large amounts in the ’50s, ’60s, ’70’s, and ’80s. The Nixon and Reagan landslides are so impressive because they were winning votes from the other side.
Good catch on the third party thing. Does anyone remember John Anderson? I certainly remember the name. But seeing as I was in second grade at the time, I don’t have a clue who he really was.
Yes, I certainly remember John Anderson (a former Republican Congressman from the Chicago area, IIRC). And, I remember watching the US ice hockey team win the Olympic gold that year.
Top Independent Voter Getters in Presidential Elections of the 20th Century:
28% – 1912 Teddy Roosevelt (Progressive). Teddy got more votes than the incumbent Republican he was feuding with (Taft).
19% – 1992 Ross Perot (Independent). Did Bill Clinton ever call to thank him? I imagine not.
17% – 1924 Robert LaFollette (Progressive). Twenty-five guys vied for the Democratic nomination. Talk about a party in turmoil. Should be a lesson for Democrats who hold a grudge, as it was a walloping landslide for Cool Calvin Coolidge (and LaFollette had split from the Republican side, at that).
14% – 1968 George Wallace (American Independent). Integration? Not down here!
9% – 1996 Ross Perot (2nd attempt, this time as Reform). The fire was gone.
7% – 1980 John Anderson (Independent). Vote for Ronald Goldwater? Never!
Wait, I thought your point was that public enthusiasms were a fragile thing? If we’re switching to “repudiation” elections then the point is lost, innit? Every one cited resulted in two terms for the incumbent party, at minimum.
There’s just way too many eggs in this pudding (can we, by the way, restrict it to elections since the invention of the Wireless, the Victrola, and the family flivver?). Ascribing a single reason to a national election is a tenuous business to begin with, even before we start qualifying what policies are or aren’t contentious. Eisenhower got 55% of the vote in 1952, and a plurality of 11%, and he replaced an incumbent Democrat, but it doesn’t qualify as a repudiation, for some reason that’s lost on me. And that’s before we get to simply ascribing a third-party candidates’ support to just one of the major candidates–and almost completely erroneously in the case of John Anderson, who was a liberal Republican (they had ’em in those days) whose brief, Let’s Change The Way Politics Is Played attraction appealed mostly to disgruntled, anti-Carter liberals.
So at this point we have Reagan, 1980, as the fifth or sixth greatest margin of victory in “repudiation” elections, out of the last twenty-four, of which a grand total of nine swapped the incumbent party, and it’s one of the top six margins since 1960, out of a total of twelve. Forgive me if I seem less than suitably impressed. Reagan’s victory in 1980 repudiated Jimmy Carter, and his electoral landslide was achieved with less than 51% of the vote, whoever those voters were. The rest is spin, something his idolaters have been busy with ever since.
(And, yeah, like one of the greatest of all Indiana Democrats, the real Senator Bayh, I support direct election of the President. This did not noticeably incline me to Senator Clinton in the late unpleasantness.)
I dunno DR, I seem to be jumping around now. My initial point was that you don’t always get what you ask for (isn’t that a Stones rip-off?). And, I went to 1912 because I wanted to get Woodrow Wilson in.
Here’s some more factoids. Candidates who have won big in the Electoral College.
1912 – Woodrow Wilson
1920 – Warren Harding
1924 – Calvin Coolidge Tail gunner
1928 – Herbert Hoover
1932/36/40/44 – FDR Master Player
1952/56 – Ike Player with practice
1964 – LBJ Player with practice
1972 – Nixon Player with practice
1980/84 – Reagan Player with practice
1988 – Bush I Tail gunner
A mixed bag in the old Presidential rankings game. Big electoral victories does not seem to necessarily equate with being a good (or bad) President. Looks more like most eventual Presidents knew which side of the bread was buttered (and the popular vote wasn’t it).
On a related note, Jimmy Carter said that a “unity” ticket was a very bad idea. For once, I agree with him. And, it applies equally to a Obama-Clinton or McCain-Romney ticket.
If that’s all their respective advisers have, then it’s time to keel haul them.