Sylvia Smith, writing for the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, has an article entitled State Democrats look to ride coattails. Indiana’s Democrats are hoping Obama will spend some time and energy on Indiana which will help down ticket races. The truth is that Obama is unlikely to spend a lot of effort on Indiana. We just aren’t the most plausible swing state. If Indiana goes blue, it will be part of a nation wide landslide as opposed to a place that was targeted and flipped.
Still, I think that Obama is likely to have longer coattails than Clinton would have. Bill Clinton never generated much in the way of coattails for down ticket races in his election campaigns. His electoral strategy, much like Hillary’s primary strategy, relied more on targeting key states than running a nationwide campaign. I think Obama is going to run more of a 50 state campaign. For what it’s worth, I think the circumstances of the 90s made Bill’s approach the right one and the circumstances of the 00s make Obama’s approach the right one. Times have changed. The problems that suggest the incumbent party need to be kicked out are broader today than they were in the 90s. In fact, when Clinton was running in ’92, the Democrats were the Congressional incumbents.
In any event, I think Mike McDaniel’s glee that the Democrats are “so split” is premature. The polls showing Clinton supporters weren’t going to vote for Obama were taken in the heat of battle. I’ve had enough of my preferred candidates lose (pretty much all of them, truth be told) that I know how this works. Anger and disappointment fade and recognition that your preferred candidate is no longer an option sets in. Then you take a look around and figure out which candidate is the best alternative. Some Clinton supporters may very well decide that McCain best reflect their views. But, I suspect the vast majority will decide that eternal war, right wingers on the Supreme Court, an executive branch full of legacy Bush appointees, and all the rest of it aren’t the best option and might cast their vote for Obama instead. (What disappointed Clinton supporters don’t need, however, is a bunch of gleeful, smug Obama supporters scolding them about their duty to support the Democrats the week after Obama clinched the nomination.)
Update A CBS poll is out showing Obama leading McCain in nationally by a margin of 48% to 42%. Obama has this lead even though 25% of Clinton supporters say they will vote for McCain in the fall. The poll was taken May 30 – June 3 while the Obama/Clinton race was still going and the Florida/Michigan issue was still festering. It will be interesting to see what that number looks like in July when passions have had time to cool.
Meanwhile, Bush is setting records in terms of disapproval ratings:
President Bush’s approval rating is at its lowest level to date. Just 25 percent of Americans approve of the overall job Mr. Bush is doing as President, an all-time low for him and among the lowest approval ratings ever recorded for a President.
Sixty-seven percent disapprove of the job Bush is doing – the highest such figure in CBS News polls since he assumed office.
Only Presidents Nixon (24 percent) and Truman (22 percent) have seen polls showing job approval ratings lower than 25 percent during their presidencies, according to Gallup Polls. President Carter’s all-time low was 26 percent.
I’m not gonna say Obama will win Indiana… but…
Check out http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/ an electoral statistics site (and run by a guy who writes for Baseball Prospectus and invented the PECOTA statistic for baseball).
His polling aggregation model has Indiana at McCain ahead 5%. We haven’t been polled on the matchup since 4/29, but that last poll had Obama +1 and Clinton +3.
So while I still don’t think Obama will win Indiana in the end, if Indiana ends up being within 5% and with Ohio being a very important swing state.. I could see him making some visits.
Plus it’s not like they have to check his passport at the Skyway birdge or anything….
Obama is going to get the 30-18 yr old vote. Thats what’s new and there is every indication that this group will come out en masse to vote this time for Obama,but would very well have stayed home for Hillary. These aren’t typical democratic party voters.Someone into statistics should be be able to calculate the strength of voter registrations in Indiana university cities and go from there.We will have new metrics in this next election.And how many middle-aged women are there in Indiana? These are the group Hillary will influence to vote for Obama.
Doug,
I agree 100%.
For the record, in this primary I supported Schellinger and Clinton. Neither of whom won.
So now what will I do?
I am going to do all I can to elect Jill Long Thompson and Barack Obama.
Pure and simple- we had a primary and I chose the candidates I liked BEST. But the system says that whomever wins the primary is our candidate and Long Thompson and Obama are clearly more aligned with my thinking than Daniels or McCain.
Doug, I’ve heard from more than a few Obama people that he will indeed spend some time in Indiana. He really believes he can put this state in play in November. I know it’s a long shot, but if there is anyone who could make Indiana Blue for the first time since Johnson (actually, it was red back then when the Dems had red and the Repubs had blue) it would be Obama.
Realclearpolitics has some electoral college maps with toss up states and no toss up states. With no toss up states included Obama has 272 electoral votes to McCain’s 266. With toss up states included it’s murkier. Now that we’re in general election mode, it’ll be interesting to see Obama’s and McCain’s strategies.
It’ll also be interesting to see how those poll numbers change now that the Democratic primary is over and McCain and Obama are scrutinized side by side.
Also, recall how much trouble the polls had with predicting those primary results. Hard telling if they’re very accurate with the general election.