Just in case some folks out there and were only half paying attention when some Clinton flack tried to push the notion that she has a higher popular vote total than Obama in the Democratic primaries, please keep in mind that the Clinton math does not include the following:
Alaska
Colorado
Hawaii
Idaho
Iowa
Kansas
Maine
Minnesota
Nebraska
Nevada
North Dakota
Texas (Caucus only)
Washington
WyomingANY popular votes for Obama in Michigan
But, other than that she’s winning. . . unless of course you consider the delegates which I had been lead to believe were the relevant metric in this particular competition. (It’s kind of like playing euchre and getting a bunch of 10s before you insist to the rest of the table that you were, in fact, playing poker.)
She is setting herself up to play the Florida 2000 card.
‘I won and the party elitists stole the election from me.’
I’ve heard it suggested that the DNC Rules Committee needed the wisdom of Solomon.
They seem to have heard that, too – witness the fact that they cut the delegates in half!
Great card analogy, Euchre isn’t playing with a full deck either.
Yeah, the only problem with this analogy is that when Solomon suggested doing this with the child in question, the real mom took a step back and said, “Let the other woman have him!” Hillary’s backers would rather kill the party.
Andrew Romano has a Newsweek article that looks at the numbers from several different angles. If you count all votes, for all states (including Florida and Michigan), and use estimates for caucaus states, she actually is ahead in the popular vote.
Meaningless, of course, as the article also points out.
how many of those would be from PR or Guam which cannot vote for US Pres? How many are not being counted from caucus states?
So, Obama gets zero votes from Michigan? That’s reasonable.
Doug said:
We aren’t talking “reasonable” – those are just the actual number of talleyed votes (ish – I don’t understand the causus estimates). I wonder…if someone in Michigan wrote in Obama on their ticket (there had to be some of those, didn’t there?), was it counted?.
“Reasonable” has to be a consideration if, but only if, the Clinton campaign is claiming that the Michigan vote is a measurement of anything about which we ought to be concerned.
According to commentary I heard during the committee hearings last Saturday there were 30,000 write-in votes for Obama in Michigan,but they couldn’t be acknowledged because Michigan law requires that a candidate indicate in advance that he is a write-in candidate,which Obama didn’t do.So the only choice for Obama voters was to vote ‘uncommitted’
Indiana law, I think, is similar. When I asked about a write-in at the primary I was told it is only counted if the person was registered as a write-in.