That’s question at the heart of this column (news article?) by Ivy Farguheson for the Muncie Star Press. The jury is out, and this election probably won’t provide conclusive evidence either. For decades, a lot of white blue collar males have voted against their economic self-interest (to the extent the Democrats represented it — the Republicans mostly did not; but that doesn’t necessarily make Democrats champions of the working class). Instead, cultural issues seem to have been more of a driving force.
There are plenty of working class types who are going to vote for the shit kickin’ cowboy and not for the egghead, white or black. The egghead is probably going to gay marry their gun during an abortion ceremony while sipping a latte in a Volvo; or something. And Barack Obama is a known eater of arugula; I hear.
Anyway, race plays into the culture wars, but it’s probably not definitive. And there are plenty of working class whites in Michigan, Iowa, Oregon, and other states tilting strongly for Obama. So, it’s not the skin color or the economic status that is determinative. I tend to think the culture of the Confederacy is stronger in Indiana — that culture probably makes a person less likely to vote for a black person, but it also probably makes a person less likely to vote for any Democrat simply because they aren’t as socially conservative. In Indiana, there are a fair number of folks who long for a return to the 50s (1950s in some cases, 1850s in others).