According to an article by Mike Smith, writing for the Associated Press, Representative Charlie Brown says he will introduce legislation to ban smoking in public places state wide.
Smoking would be snuffed out in almost all enclosed public places in Indiana, including restaurants, bars, bowling alleys and casinos, under a bill a powerful state lawmaker plans to push in the upcoming legislative session.
“It is a public health issue,†said Democratic state Rep. Charlie Brown of Gary, chairman of the House Public Health Committee. He said his primary aim is protecting the health of non-smokers who work in places where smoking is allowed.
(I wonder if Mike died a little bit inside when he wrote “smoking would be snuffed out”.)
Smoking is a tricky one, civil liberties-wise. Your right to swing your arms ends at the tip of my nose, as the saying goes. If smokers could find a way to keep their smoke out of my air, I would have more sympathy for their arguments about their rights being infringed when these smoking bans are implemented. But then, you get a whole new layer when you start asking whose air it is at a public establishment with employees: Do patrons have a claim on the air? Do employees have a claim on the air? The owner of the business? The landlord of the business?
As I’ve said before, libertarianism doesn’t deal well with pollution. It’s hard to keep particulate matter out of the air and water, it’s hard to determine when and how much that particulate matter is damaging someone else, and it’s hard to find a cost-effective remedy for such damage once it has been caused. Smoking is a form of pollution.
Another question is to ask whether smoking regulations are better handled at the federal, state, or local level. I don’t have strong opinions there. It’s not based on strong convictions, but I suppose I’d like to see a regime where smoking is permitted at places with other “vices” — bars and casinos and the like, but not at other public venues.
(As a matter of my own personal comfort, I would like it if I never had to encounter cigarette smoke anywhere. I hate the stuff — it smells awful, it makes my clothes reek, if my wife goes somewhere smoky, I end up having to smell it in her hair, and I have unpleasant memories of the smoke filled car on family trips when my parents used to smoke. Generally, when I have to encounter it, cigarette smoke decreases my quality of life to one extent or another.)