That was fast. The New York Times is reporting that the Second Circuit is rejecting Indiana’s Appeal of the bankruptcy court’s decision to allow the sale of Chrysler. The sale will be stayed until Monday afternoon to allow the funds to attempt to get the Supreme Court to take up the matter.
Democratic Walk-Out of Budget Hearings
Niki Kelly has a good article on the Democratic walk-out from the committee hearing yesterday. They did so to protest what they saw as staged public testimony and what they see as misleading representations by Gov. Daniels on education funding.
The only thing I would have added to Ms. Kelly’s reporting is perhaps the text of the solicitation for testimony sent by the Indiana Republicans. Jim Shella had this on his blog:
The Indiana Republican Party sent out an e-mail today looking for taxpayers to testify in favor of Governor Mitch Daniels’ budget at a legislative committee meeting tomorrow. (The committee is mid-identified in the e-mail as the Legislative Council.)
The e-mail includes these instructions: “Testimony need only be 2-3 minutes and should include details about your story (i.e. a concerned taxpayer, small business owner, 18-year-old who would inherit the debt, retiree, young family just out of school, etc). —
Based on his comment, to Ms. Kelly, Senator Luke Kenley seems to be keeping a cool head and not burning bridges. He said of the Democratic walk-out:
“I’m concerned. This is a blow to our cooperation,†said Sen. Luke Kenley, R-Noblesville. “The Democrats feel like they are being backed into a corner. There are fewer revenue dollars, which means fewer solutions. And they don’t like the solutions.â€
Meanwhile, the concern about Gov. Daniels representations about education funding has to do with the fact that state funding for education will increase by only about 0.25%. (I presume that none of this is adjusted for inflation, meaning that in terms of real dollars, we’ll be spending less on education.) When Gov. Daniels claims a 2% increase, he’s counting federal stimulus dollars.
Fort Wayne Community Schools Superintendent Wendy Robinson told the committee it misleads the public to include the federal stimulus money in the state-funding calculation.
“We know we’re going to have to take a hit, so let’s be clear about what that hit is,†she said.
For instance, under Daniels’ proposal, the base state funding for FWCS in 2009 is $196 million and would drop to $195 million in 2010 – a 0.5 percent cut. A similar cut would come in 2011.
In comparison, under previous budget proposals this year, FWCS would have seen a modest increase due to several factors in the school-funding formula that Daniels’ plan removed.
Also, it turns out, federal dollars can’t be spent in the same way as state money. For example, it is not appropriate to spend such money on ongoing expenses like electric bills or staff salaries.
And, speaking of Mitch Daniels, be sure to check out Doghouse Riley’s thoughts on the recent talk of him considering a Presidential run in 2012.
Arguments in Chrysler BK Appeal Today
The Second Circuit will hear arguments in the Chrysler bankruptcy appeal today. The appeal is spearheaded by Indiana pension funds and state treasurer Richard Mourdock.
The old saw in legal circles is that, if the law is on your side, pound on the law. If the facts are on your side, pound on the facts. If neither is on your side, pound on the table. From the excerpt quoted by the news sources I’ve seen, the Indiana funds are pounding on the table.
“This attack on the most fundamental of creditor rights has been funded, orchestrated and controlled by Treasury, despite its complete lack of statutory and Constitutional authority to do so.â€
The facts seem to be, according to the bankruptcy court (court order – pdf) after hearing evidence, that the plan approved by the bankruptcy court will yield more money to first priority creditors than they would have gotten out of a liquidation. (See my prior analysis here.) The only distributions being made for pre-bankruptcy petition debts will go to the first priority lenders, including the Indiana pension funds. Junior lienholders and unsecured creditors who will receive a benefit from the New Chrysler going forward do so because of new value they are contributing.
In addition, Indiana appears to have waived its right to challenge the bankruptcy plan by virtue of the investment agreement it signed on to. The first priority creditors signed onto an investment agreement whereby the investors agreed to be bound by the actions of an administrator. To take certain actions, the administrator had to get the approval of a certain percentage of the dollars invested — seems to have been a one-dollar, one-vote kind of deal. The Indiana funds are an extremely minor player in this investment fund, holding something like 0.6% of the total stake. The administrator received the approval of something like 96% of the dollars held. Now, the Indiana funds are trying to paint this as some sort of brave stand — Mourdock is bold enough to act where the rest of the financial giants were cowed into obeisance by the mighty federal government. The more likely explanation is that this is the best deal available under the circumstances. Political gain is what Mourdock and, perhaps, the Daniels administration hope to realize from this challenge.
I am curious about a couple of aspects related to this First Lien Credit Agreement to which the Indiana funds are subject. First of all, if the other creditors under the agreement are (as the Indiana funds seem to be suggesting) breaching their fiduciary duty by acquiescing to a bad deal because of political pressure; will the Indiana funds zealously protect their investment by suing its fellow creditors for the losses experienced because of this breach. If Mourdock is doing this for political gain, clearly the answer is “no.” If he truly believes his public position, then the answer should be “yes.” I suspect the former.
The other aspect of the First Lien Credit Agreement about which I am curious is whether the Indiana funds are opening themselves up to a suit themselves from their fellow creditors. I have to imagine that if the Indiana funds are acting outside of the terms of the agreement and, by doing so, cost their fellow investors money, there is some provision for those fellow creditors to make a claim against the Indiana funds. Given that those funds have at stake 96 times the money of the Indiana funds, the exposure could be substantial.
Guess we’ll have to wait and see what the Second Circuit does with this.
Daniels offers platitudes to conservatives
Maybe he had concrete solutions to offer, but from this Maureen Groppe piece, during a speech to the right-wing Hudson Institute think tank, Gov. Daniels mostly had platitudes to offer as conservatives’ way back to power. His recommendations:
#Forward-looking;
#Constructive
#Friendly
#Patient
#Espouse Freedom
#Anti-mass transit, small cars, or “homogenized” health care
#Stress deficits when analyzing plans
#Don’t be negative, backward looking, or bereft of new ideas
#Have big ideas on the table and major changes underway
#Talk to people as adults and take risks
#Feel average Americans’ hopes, dreams, concerns, and fears
He also suggested that people chose Obama as a fashion statement. Which is funny considering Daniels’ admonition against being negative, backward looking, and bereft of new ideas; and for having big ideas for major changes. The Republicans in 2008 were a litany of old ideas. If we had a nickel for every time a Republican candidate longingly looked back to Ronald Reagan, we probably could have paid back the debt Reagan exploded. But probably not the debt generated during Daniels’ tenure in charge of the budget. I guess there was always “Drill Baby, Drill” — that was certainly a big idea delivered to people as if they were adults.
Mad Anthony Brewing
Dan Stockman, writing for the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, has a nice write up about the Mad Anthony Brewing Company. I haven’t had the pleasure of visiting one of their restaurants, but occasionally I can find a store in Lafayette that sells their beer, and it has always been fine stuff. Mad Anthony, along with Three Floyds and Oaken Barrel are probably my three favorite Indiana brewing companies. (This is probably a betrayal of my own Lafayette Brewing Company, but I’m still recovering from the Tippecanoe Common Ale which I really didn’t like — the Black Angus Oatmeal Stout is really good though.)
Indiana and the Chrysler Bankruptcy
Some of my fellow Hoosier bloggers (h/t Abdul and Josh Claybourn) have been following the Chrysler bankruptcy, particularly with respect to Indiana’s unexpectedly prominent role in the matter. Josh, in particular, has strong feelings on the issue, calling the proposed reorganization (presumably with some degree of hyperbole “The End of Capitalism as We Know It.”)
For those who haven’t been following the matter, Indiana Treasurer Richard Mourdock has been spearheading objections to the reorganization plan because of its affect on approximately $42 million nominally owed to the Indiana State Teachers Retirement Fund, the Indiana State Pension Trust and the Indiana Major Moves Construction Fund for investments these funds made in Chrysler. This represents about 0.6% of the $6.9 billion in first priority liens against Chrysler’s assets. However, despite Indiana’s very minor position among this class of creditors, it is the one raising the biggest stink and trying the hardest to derail the process. Chrysler smells politics. So do I. Under the proposed plan, Indiana will receive a return of about 29%.
This is an issue that journalists and Indiana politicians should probably be familiar with going forward. Maybe I’m wrong, but this has the smell of Mourdock and, potentially, Gov. Daniels trying to set themselves up politically as champions of the marketplace and defenders against Obama’s nefarious economic plots. If the bankruptcy court’s description (pdf) of the evidence presented bears any resemblance to what was actually presented, Indiana’s pursuit of these claims looks like a waste of taxpayer money – first there is no apparent alternative that would yield more money to the Indiana funds than the one being approved by the court; and second Indiana invested in Chrysler subject to an agreement that requires the Indiana funds to go along with the decisions of fellow investors that control a vastly greater share of the funds invested. Those creditors have consented to the deal with Fiat for a New Chrysler.
Much more after the jump.
Special Session June 11
The 2009 Special Session of the Indiana General Assembly will commence June 11.
Daniels told members of the bipartisan State Budget Committee on Tuesday that the special legislative session would begin Monday. Daniels said he hopes that give lawmakers plenty of time to agree on a spending plan before the current budget expires on June 30.
Update Some confusion with the AP story. It won’t start on Monday, but on the 11th of June — Thursday. (Per WTHR and Jim Shella.)
7th Circuit Declines Application of Heller to State Handgun Bans
The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals decided the case of National Rifle Association v. City of Chicago. The suit was filed by the NRA and others against the City of Chicago and Village of Oak Park which have ordinances that ban the possession of most forms of handguns. The suit was filed in the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision in District of Columbia v. Heller which struck down D.C.’s handgun ban.
The Seventh Circuit declined to apply Heller to subdivisions of the state, reasoning that Heller applied the Second Amendment to the federal government. In the past, the Supreme Court has rebuffed efforts to apply the Second Amendment to the states. In this case, Judge Easterbrook reasoned that, while the rationales for not applying the Second Amendment to the states may well have been undermined by subsequent decisions, it was the Supreme Court’s prerogative — and not that of the Seventh Circuit — to bury past Supreme Court precedent when the time comes.
Mining the Economy
In today’s New York Times, Paul Krugman argues that St. Ronald started the financial deregulation ball rolling that left us vulnerable to the current economic crisis.
The immediate effect of Garn-St. Germain, as I said, was to turn the thrifts from a problem into a catastrophe. The S.& L. crisis has been written out of the Reagan hagiography, but the fact is that deregulation in effect gave the industry — whose deposits were federally insured — a license to gamble with taxpayers’ money, at best, or simply to loot it, at worst. By the time the government closed the books on the affair, taxpayers had lost $130 billion, back when that was a lot of money.
But there was also a longer-term effect. Reagan-era legislative changes essentially ended New Deal restrictions on mortgage lending — restrictions that, in particular, limited the ability of families to buy homes without putting a significant amount of money down.
The deregulation led to an explosion of debt, public and private. Essentially, I think, we’ve been mining the economy for the past quarter century instead of growing it. Now we’re left with the economic equivalent of a Superfund site.
To be a little bit fair, I’m not sure if continuing to grow the economy was a viable option as the rest of the world began to catch up to us. But, by mining the economy instead of conserving it, we’ve probably multiplied the resulting problems. Guess we’ll see.
Priorities
Now that the legislature has to go into a special session, Gov. Daniels finally joined the budget conversation in earnest. The AP has an outline of his budget cuts:
Financial aid (+3%)
K-12 (+2%)
State police (flat)
Prisons (flat)
College (-4%)
State parks (-8%)
“Faith based & community initiatives” (-10%) (In quotes b/c I don’t know what these programs are.)
Homeland security (-10%)
Environmental Management (-11%)
BMV (-11%)
Health (-12%)
Libraries (-15%)
I wonder what this means for the state’s Medicaid appropriation. As I recall, it’s usually one of the (if not the) highest single line item in the budget, but I’m not sure how much control the General Assembly has over it.
Incidentally, Everybody’s Favorite Economist, Larry DeBoer had a Capital Comments column in April about Indiana’s revenue shortfall, the stimulus, and what it means for Indiana’s budget. It’s either pain now or pain later, or both. When it’s time to cut, we can really identify our priorities as a community. I’m not sure I’ll enjoy what the true priorities of our leaders are, but it’s probably time to find out.
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 277
- 278
- 279
- 280
- 281
- …
- 690
- Next Page »