Gov. Daniels will give his State of the State address tonight. I’m a little bit indifferent. He’s been in office for 5 years. I don’t expect any real initiatives out of him at this point. I get the feeling that the General Assembly is sort of steering the ship at this point. Probably I just haven’t been paying attention, but my snap recollection of Gov. Daniels for the past couple of years is: 1) loads of flashy ads; 2) general campaigning against an anemic opponent; 3) nothing during the last legislative session; 4) until he raised his head at the last minute to torpedo the budget deal and force a special session (instead of just working with the budget process from the get go); 5) some friendly back & forth with the Maryland governor; and 6) here we are.
SJR 13 – Proposed Marriage Amendment
Sen. Yoder has introduced SJR 13 which seeks to create a constitutional definition of marriage. This is a variation on the continued panic in some circles about the potential for equal treatment under the law for gay people. A similar marriage amendment failed to pass the last General Assembly and therefore never got on the ballot. Now the process has to start over. This iteration says:
Only a marriage between one (1) man and one (1) woman shall be valid or recognized as a marriage in Indiana. A legal status identical or substantially similar to that of marriage for unmarried individuals shall not be valid or recognized.
It struck me that a fair reading of this language could lead to the non-recognition of second or third marriages. Maybe they should add a parenthetical between “woman” and “shall” that says “(at a time).”
The second sentence is obviously aimed at civil unions, but the net it casts is awfully wide, catching unmarried heterosexual partners as well. “Substantially similar legal status” is an awfully murky phrase, particularly from those purportedly nervous about “activist judges.”
I’m just flat against this kind of legislation. I’ve described my progression before, but for those just tuning in: Growing up, I thought of myself as anti-gay, because I didn’t know any gay people. Or, more accurately, I didn’t know I knew any gay people. Turns out a non-trivial number of guys I knew growing up and in college were gay. (Sorry if I said or did anything to offend, gentlemen). Once I met a guy I new to be gay, being “anti-gay” quickly seemed silly. He was, in most respects, just like anyone else I knew, and it seemed awfully small of me to dislike him simply because of who he loved. But, from there, I probably only got as far as indifferent to gay issues. I wasn’t against them, but they weren’t important to me either.
Now, I’ve progressed to being affirmatively in favor of allowing gay marriage. There just isn’t any rational basis for opposing it. If your God tells you to work against gays, I guess that’s between you and him. But the State’s supposed interest in promoting procreation is just hogwash. If that were anything but a pretext, you’d see prohibitions on marriage by post-menopausal women and sterile men. Working from the presumption that sexual orientation is a birthright and not a “lifestyle choice,” denying gay people such a fundamental right for no good reason seems gratuitously mean.
Bradner on the Sound & Fury of the General Assembly So Far
Eric Bradner has a column in the Evansville Courier Press discussing the progress of the General Assembly so far. He points out that they haven’t actually done anything all that significant yet. The property tax Constitutional amendment is politically popular, and it won’t actually change anything directly — the property tax caps are already law. Township “reform” is pretty much just passing the buck. They allow for local referendums on whether to eliminate townships. They can claim to have done something about the Kernan-Shepard report while at the same time telling their colleagues in township government that they never voted to eliminate the position. I’m not sure the ethics bill fits Bradner’s narrative especially well, but his point is well taken – it involves relatively small changes in response to what is perceived to be a big problem.
Big changes, suggests Bradner, would be moving on Sen. Becker & Rep. Crouch’s proposal to make Medicaid waiver eligibility presumptive for at-home elder care, thereby reducing the hardship involved with sometimes lengthy eligibility determinations. Or, he suggests, redistricting reform could move forward. (On that, see a good analysis of Rokita’s disingenuous craftiness on the subject.) In addition, net metering could be important as could gaming issues.
So far, there has been a little sizzle, but the meat remains to be seen.
Colts over Ravens 20-3 in AFC Divisional Game
I know what’s coming; Eighteen’s coming.
–Ed Reed, Baltimore Ravens
So, I was grumpy about the Colts pulling their starters against the Jet a few weeks back. I got over it after 2 or 3 days. It was good to have a meaningful game to wash away that sour taste. The media was full of predictions that the Ravens would run over the Colts and their stingy D would overpower a rusty, bye-jinxed Colts offense. Turns out, not so much.
The Colts defense was stingy, allowing only 3 points. The Ravens were shut out for the last 47 minutes of the game. A good bit of that was their own doing – having penalties wipe out good plays. But, for a lot of those, the penalized conduct was instrumental to the good play: no block in the back = no long run back, etc. The Colts offense was effective. You can’t say enough about Manning and the receiving corps. Reggie Wayne, in particular, made some excellent catches under tight pressure. The running game was mostly non-existent. With respect to the running game, it is baffling to me how the O line can keep a good pocket in place for Manning when it’s a pass play, but it’s like a sieve when Manning goes to hand it off. Probably there is an easy explanation the more football savvy would know.
Next week, the Colts will host the AFC Championship game against the winner of the Jets/Chargers game today. I think either one will be tough. I think the Colts are capable of beating either one. Even losing the past two seasons to the Chargers, I still don’t feel the same grudge or sense of uneasiness I always did against the Patriots. In any case, this football stuff is a whole lot of fun.
Hot Reform and a Short Session
Bill Ruthhart, writing for the Indianapolis Star, has an article suggesting that legislators contemplate making the short session even shorter. They got off to a fast start, so maybe they’ll leave Indianapolis early.
This is an election year, and legislators are eager to get back to their district to raise money and run their campaigns as soon as possible, particularly in the closely contested House.
It also doesn’t hurt that lawmakers on both sides of the aisle will be able to laud passing the constitutional property tax caps before Gov. Mitch Daniels gives his televised State of the State speech Tuesday.
“I don’t care what causes it. It’s results always that matter to us,” Daniels said of the legislature’s fast start. “I’d like to think they simply want to continue a hot streak of reform that Indiana’s been on, and everybody’s gotten with the program. But if there’s some political calculation, that’s just fine.
So, Gov. Daniels is still going with the “hot streak” thing. If this is a “hot streak,” I’d hate to see what merely making the best of a bad situation looks like. Gov. Daniels offers the opinion that the legislature is off to a strong start and, that being the case, he’ll just “stay out of their way.”
If memory serves, he stayed out of the way long enough last session that they couldn’t meet his budget demands without a special session. Seems like he stayed out of the way as the property tax debacle was coming to a head as well. And, so far as I can tell, he is still staying out of the way of the unemployment insurance fund shortfall. He’s not the only one, of course. A number of lawmakers have tried to steer clear of leadership on tough questions. Since his first session in 2005, Daniels’ M.O. has been to mostly disappear while the legislature is in session. Given the “car bomb” incident, that might make some sense. But, I just thought I should make a note of that in case he does decide to run for President and start making claims about what a leader he is. Selling a road and screwing with our clocks is no substitute for getting your hands dirty when the legislature is in town.
In any case, I suppose the General Assembly might clear out earlier than they have to, but it probably won’t be as early as the fabled year when they were gone by Valentine’s Day. I suspect that year is still remembered fondly by legislative staffers.
The legislature is doing stuff
Paying work has kind of taken over my life the past couple of days. Sorry ’bout that. I hear the legislature has been doing stuff though. Feel free to discuss it.
Indiana Urban Counties Subsidize Rural Counties
Mary Beth Schneider, writing for the Indianapolis Star, has an article about a study (pdf) released by John Ketzenberger’s Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute suggesting that Indiana’s urban counties pay out more tax dollars than they get back while the reverse is true for the rural counties.
Of the state’s 92 counties, the 46 considered “metropolitan” paid 82.5 percent of taxes, while getting back 76.7 percent of revenue.
The top 10 donor counties, the study found, were Vanderburgh, Hendricks, Hamilton, Bartholomew, Monroe, Dubois, Marion, Steuben, Clark and Kosciusko.
The top 10 recipients, getting back more dollars than they paid in, were Cass, Sullivan, Parke, Miami, Clay, Union, Crawford, Perry, Jennings and Jefferson.
I guess I’m surprised to hear that half of Indiana’s counties are “metropolitan.”
I only glanced at the report, but it suggests that Steuben County was a “donor” county because of its interstates and proximity to other states, resulting in a high rate of collection of gasoline and cigarette taxes. Kosciusko, Dubois, and Adams counties, the study suggests, are donor counties despite being rural because they have residents who work in nearby metropolitan areas and, consequently, have relatively higher incomes. I only glanced at the report for an explanation of why Cass was such a net recipient county, but didn’t see an explanation if it was there. My guess would be the presence of Logansport State Hospital.
SB 171 – Reporting of Medical Loss Ratios
Sen. Becker has introduced SB 171 which would require health insurers to report medical loss ratios. In the health insurance biz, money spent on actually paying for health care is regarded as “medical loss.” Sen. Becker’s bill would require health insurers to report what percentage of premiums are used to pay for health care as opposed to other stuff like salaries, marketing, hiring staff to deny claims, etc. The idea – for customers, anyway – is that the best health insurer is the one that is best able to translate premium dollars into health care payments. Investors and other stakeholders might prefer that premium dollars get diverted to other pockets.
The bill requires accounting for specific categories of expenditures, including: Chief executive officer and executive salaries and benefits; Advertising and marketing expenses; Travel and entertainment expenses; and State and federal lobbying expenses.
SB 141 – Contraception
Senator Vi Simpson has introduced SB 141 which tries to exempt contraception from the abortion laws.
It defines contraception as “the use of a drug or device that has been approved by the federal Food and Drug Administration to prevent pregnancy.” Then it says that “contraception” is not subject to IC 16-34 which sets forth the public policy on abortion and criminalizes the performance of an abortion except under specified conditions.
It’s remarkable how often the same people who oppose abortion also seem to oppose contraception or sex education. Credibility for the argument that the real concern is the sanctity of human life would be enhanced by support for reproductive rights when they clearly do not involve the life of a child. Widespread contraception and sex education are much more effective at reducing the need for abortions than, say, abstinence only education.
I have not come to a full understanding about why conservative morality so frequently seems to involve controlling a woman’s sexuality. And, by “conservative morality” I’m not talking specifically about politics in the United States in the 20th and 21st century. This sort of thing seems to crop up in conservative strains of different religions in different times. At some point, I guess I ought to try to understand the source of the impulse to control women in this fashion.
House Passes Two Bills & One Resolution
The House passed HB 1001 and HB 1002 by votes of 97-2 and 61-38, respectively. HB 1001 had to do with lobbying and ethics, and HB 1002 had to do with preferences for Indiana companies in public works projects.
In case you were curious, the two “no” votes against HB 1001 were Tim Brown (R-Crawfordsville) and Dave Wolkins (R-Winona Lake).
The House also passed HJR 1, which takes the property tax cap law that’s already in place and enshrines it in the Constitution for future generations to enjoy regardless of whether it ends up being good policy or not. The resolution passed by a vote of 75 – 23. If it passes the Senate, which it probably will, then it will be up to The People to vote. Perhaps I underestimate the attentiveness of my fellow Hoosiers, but when it comes time to vote on this, I’d be surprised if 1/2 the people casting votes do so with the understanding that these tax caps are already the law; it will save them exactly nothing in property taxes – at least in the near term; and all they will be doing is make things harder to fix if the Law of Unintended Consequences rears its ugly head. But, I guess if you get to campaign on being Tough on Taxes, it’s all worth it.
Update Abdul has published an excerpt from a letter sent by the Indiana Association of Cities and Towns to legislators. It responds to legislators who claimed that local officials didn’t “make the case” forcefully enough against Constitutionalizing property tax caps. What that seems to mean is that the locals didn’t provide enough political cover for legislators to vote against this block of text making its way into our Constitution.
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 241
- 242
- 243
- 244
- 245
- …
- 690
- Next Page »