I was just clued in to a lefty blog run out of Notre Dame called Lefty’s Last Cry. Might be worth checking out.
Republican Senate Primary
The candidates running to be the Republican nominee for Senate blamed the spending on the Democrats. And, in other news, the sun rose in the east.
The candidates – former U.S. Sen. Dan Coats, former Rep. John Hostettler, state Sen. Marlin Stutzman of Howe, financial adviser Don Bates Jr. of Winchester and Fishers businessman Richard Behney – all took part in the two-hour round table at River of Life Community Church.
. . .
They did little to distinguish themselves on the issues Saturday, all blaming Obama and the Democratic-controlled Congress for runaway government spending and bigger government.
If you disagree with current federal spending levels, and there is an argument to be made, I would suggest that you can’t expect much relief from candidates who simply blame the other party. Democrats have to own the fact that they’re the party in control at the moment, have controlled Congress since 2007, and have controlled the White House since 2009. Republicans have to own the fact that federal spending and budgets were under much better control before Bush and the Republican Congresses of the early 2000s.
Candidates who don’t understand (or won’t acknowledge) how we got where we are currently aren’t likely to be able to do much about getting us somewhere else. Just saying “the other side sucks,” won’t cut it. Mind you, this isn’t an argument for bipartisanship just for bipartisanship’s sake; just that there is blame to go around — though, not necessarily equally apportioned among both major political parties. I once read that only the powerless can ever truly be innocent; which, I suppose, explains some of the appeal of 3rd parties in our country.
Food Fight!
Andy Gammill has an article in the Indy Star reporting on the dismal relations between (almost featured Creationist Evidence Speaker) State Superintendent of Public Instruction, Tony Bennett, and the state teacher’s union. They seem to be communicating primarily via inflammatory press releases.
This reminds me a bit of a lesson I learned about communication early on in my legal career (probably earlier – it’s no big secret). I was exchanging letters with another attorney that were becoming increasingly contentious. I was about to escalate with another letter when it occurred to me how stupid we were being. I picked up the phone and had a very cordial conversation, and we resolved the issue which wasn’t all that intractable. The immediacy of speaking to one another tends to put a limit on bellicosity. Speaking in person even moreso. It’s easy to be a Big Man via e-mail.
That said, Bennett does come off looking ridiculous in one particular noted by the article. The State is in the process of applying for a federal “Race to the Top” education grant where there is a pool of about $4.4 billion available to the states. He wants teacher’s union leaders to endorse a plan that he won’t let them see.
Bennett held several meetings with union leaders but declined to allow them to see the proposal for the federal grant, saying that other states might steal the more innovative ideas. Both unions were then asked to write letters of support — for a proposal they had not seen.
Reminds me of Nixon’s secret plan to win the Vietnam War. But, then, I’m a cynic.
Holy Melodrama, Batman!
Justin Mack, writing for the Journal & Courier, has an article about the tea party rally in Lafayette yesterday. Mostly they got together on the government-built footbridge and talked about freedom and stuff. But this caught my attention:
As hundreds of people placed both tea bags and loose-leaf tea into the box, a trumpet player played Taps while a copy of the U.S. Constitution was lowered into the Wabash River — an act that was to serve as a eulogy for the document.
That old Constitution has been killed more times than Rasputin. Long may she live.
Mourdock Continues Tilting at a Windmill Named Chrysler
Maureen Hayden, writing for Community Newspaper Holdings Inc., has a story about State Treasurer Richard Mourdock’s never ending battle with Indiana’s money in the Chrysler bankruptcy. (h/t to reader RG).
In a court filing that has received little public attention, attorneys for the Indiana state worker pension funds are asking a federal appeals court to vacate a bankruptcy court’s order that cleared the way for Chrysler to sell its assets to a purchasing group lead by Italian car maker Fiat, the U.S. government and the automakers union.
I’ll be getting a little out of my depth here, but they seem to be hanging their hat on the thin reed of a Munsingwearorder from the United States Supreme Court. Generally speaking, a Munsingwear order is issued when a case becomes moot before it can be subjected to appellate review. The idea is that the case is over, so the appellate courts aren’t allowed to review it, but you don’t want to have potentially bad law remain on the books simply because an appellate court doesn’t have a chance to offer correction to the lower court.
On December 14, 2009, the United States Supreme Court issued a brief order, stating:
On petition for writ of certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Motion of Washington Legal Foundation, et al. for leave to file a brief as amici curiae granted. Petition for writ of certiorari granted. Judgment vacated, and case remanded to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit with instructions to dismiss the appeal as moot. See United States v. Munsingwear, Inc., 340 U.S. 36, 71 S.Ct. 104, 95 L.Ed. 36 (1950).
I haven’t gone over the Supreme Court briefs with any thoroughness, but the mootness argument seems to have been one made by the respondents and fought against by the petitioners (i.e. Indiana Pension Fund). In declaring the case moot, the Supreme Court seems to have found against Mourdock, but there was the additional factor of the Munsingwear rule.
With the Second Circuit appellate order cleared, the Indiana Pension Funds seem to have taken this as an opening to try to wade into the original bankruptcy order again. On March 8, 2010, the Indiana pensioners filed a petition for rehearing. An answer to that Petition was filed on April 9. I have not been able to locate a copy of the petition for rehearing. If the prior Second Circuit opinion was vacated by the Supreme Court, not because it was wrong, necessarily, but because the case was moot – no live issues were left to be resolved – then it strikes me as extraordinary to think that the Second Circuit would even have jurisdiction to rehear the case. Article III, sec. 2 of the United States Constitution limits the jurisdiction of federal courts to “cases or controversies.” The Supreme Court’s declaration that the case was moot seems to be a declaration that the case is dead – at least as to the issues covered by the Second Circuit’s ruling.
And, of course, there is the fundamental issue I’ve asked all along: there is no scenario under which the Indiana Pension funds would have recovered more money than they actually did. So why is the state treasurer pursuing this with such vigor and at such expense?
Prior blog entries on the issue:
Indiana Funds Request to Delay Chrysler Bankruptcy Denied
Indiana and the Chrysler Bankruptcy
Arguments in the Chrysler BK Appeal Today
Supreme Court Lifts Stay in Chrysler Bankruptcy; Mourdock’s Challenge Denied
Candidates Miss Filing Deadlines
For people auditioning to become one of the foremost lawmakers in the country and, really, among the most powerful people on the planet, these fellas aren’t inspiring a lot of confidence in their organizational skills or legal acumen.
Four of the five GOP candidates in the May 4 U.S. Senate primary in Indiana failed to file their personal financial disclosure statements by the required deadline this month.
Marlin Stutzman is the only one who met the deadline. Dan Coats “relied on faulty advice.” Don Bates claimed “some ambiguity in the deadline.” John Hostettler was waiting on someone to send him a packet. Richard Behney didn’t provide any information.
If one of these guys becomes Senator, that person will, no doubt, contribute to a legal system where the little people get hamstrung when they blow a deadline.
Court of Appeals Upholds Frivolous Litigant Fee Requirement
In the case of Smith v. Wrigley, the Indiana Court of Appeals has upheld the constitutionality of IC 34-10-1-3 which provides:
If an offender has filed at least three (3) civil actions in which a state court has dismissed the action or a claim under IC 34-58-1-2, the offender may not file a new complaint or petition as an indigent person under this chapter, unless a court determines the offender is in immediate danger of serious bodily injury.
Basically, this means that an inmate has to pay a filing fee before pursuing a suit after having had three prior suits dismissed as frivolous. This statute was passed after the Supreme Court struck down, at Mr. Smith’s request, a prior statute designed to limit frivolous litigation. That prior statute prohibited pursuing the claim at all. This statute just says the inmate has to pay the filing fee.
Mr. Smith, the most active appellate litigant in the state, so far as I can tell, will undoubtedly ask the Supreme Court to review this decision. I get the sense that the Court of Appeals is more annoyed by shotgun litigation by inmates than the Supreme Court, so it will be interesting to see if the Court of Appeals decision gets reviewed and, if so, whether it will stand.
What Would Happen if Taxes Were Really Low?
Mike Kole has a good piece up over at Kole Hard Facts of Life on jobs, taxes, and declining population. Be sure to check out the comments.
One thing that I realized while reading that piece was that I have an assumption about what would happen in communities where we drop taxes to skeletal levels. And that assumption is a lot different than what I think I see from Mike and certainly from other libertarians. I don’t have a lot of proof that my assumptions are right. I suspect that the libertarians do not, either. And there are always other factors at work, so I’m not certain we’ll ever get a properly controlled experiment.
My ideal economic world is a place where those who work hard and/or cleverly will prosper, where those who don’t work hard and/or work stupidly will suffer, and where the vast middle who work reasonably hard do reasonably well. In this desire, I believe I’m aligned with most of my libertarian friends and many others.
The difference is in opinions to the most feasible path to that place. I think libertarians, by and large, believe that if you lower taxes and limit regulation enough, that economic world will pretty much materialize. With the resulting solid base of industrious middle class citizens, communities will thrive.
Meanwhile, I guess I have more of a dystopian view that if you lower taxes and/or regulation much from current levels, you’ll end up in an economic world more like the Gilded Age or Mexico where a tiny few will amass wealth and have sufficient leverage to ensure that the vast majority work extremely hard just to survive and add to the vast wealth of those few who have the leverage and resources. These subsistence level citizens will not have the time or the money to tend to their communities which will fall into squalor and disrepair.
I would love to find out that my fears are misplaced and their view is correct.
Riverboat Casinos: Largest Job Creation Program Ever
I’m not going to have time to do justice to this article by Pam Tharp about a candidate forum in West College Corner, Indiana, but I had to at least take the time to highlight an interesting statement by state Senator Johnny Nugent in response to a question about things he’s done to create jobs in his district.
Nugent said he authored the largest job creation program ever — riverboat casinos — with gambling revenue the third-largest contributor to the state treasury.
Makes me think of the good old days of American prosperity, Dad heading off to work early, hard hat and lunch pail in hand, ready for a long day of dealing blackjack and making this country strong.
(The rest of the article is worth a read and brings up some substantive points I really ought to address.)
IN-04: Education & Federal Policy
The Journal & Courier is probably the best place to go for information about the extremely crowded ballot for Indiana’s Fourth Congressional District. Steve Buyer decided to step down, leaving an open seat. This started a run to fill it. The Journal & Courier asked the candidates about federal education spending.
On the Democratic side, Tara Nelson suggested that the federal government should be available to shore up shortfalls locally, particularly ensuring things like language, arts, music and sports as well as providing for four year community colleges for middle and lower income families. David Sanders recommended more equitable funding, eliminating unfunded mandates and giving local control to the schools. Federal loans should improve affordability and reliance on standardized tests should be reduced.
On the Republican side, Jon Acton says stakeholders should be “held accountable for future success.” He is also against unfunded mandates, and thinks communities that desire local control should not be punished.
I didn’t really understand Cheryl Denise Allen’s response, but here it is: “I am pleased with the grant programs issued by the government. Any student that needs money is provided for through this program. Some funds similar to these are initiated through K-12. Maybe make tuition programs for the lower grades might be a possibility.”
Jim Hass wants school boards to set standards for themselves, wants parents to set standards for their children, and wants children to govern their own behavior. He thinks the federal government should encourage efforts in math and science and thinks that experimentation should be allowed by lower levels of government.
Brandt Hershman says that, for the most part, he wants state and local government rather than the federal government setting standards for education. (That’s pretty much the status quo, right?)
Todd Rokita’s answer started off pretty boilerplate then got a little garbled: ” I support expanding the affordability of higher education, simplifying the financial aid system and undoing the government takeover of student loans to increase access to financial aid.” The federal government made changes to the federal student loan program. Not sure how the federal government can “take over” its own program. There are efforts afoot to cut out the middle man for federally guaranteed loans. So, the most charitable I can be is to conclude that Secretary of State Rokita doesn’t understand the issue terribly well.
Mark Seitz says that federal funding should be used to support K-12 education but money accepted comes with a requirement that certain standards should be met.
PJ Steffens & Eric Wathen want to get rid of the Department of Education and unfunded mandates.
Daniel Dunham, Charlie Henderson, and Mike Young think the federal government has no business doing anything with education. Henderson supports “states rights.” (Follow up for Mr. Henderson or any states’ rights purist: does the sanctity of states rights extend to drug legalization?)
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 229
- 230
- 231
- 232
- 233
- …
- 690
- Next Page »