Eric Bradner, writing for the Evansville Courier Press, has an article about how the Chrysler Bankruptcy is playing into the Indiana Treasurer’s race between incumbent Richard Mourdock and challenger Pete Buttigieg.
At issue is Mourdock’s decision to go glory-hound with a legal challenge to the decision of the Chrysler bankruptcy court, costing Hoosiers a pile of money. What I have never seen described – and I have been paying some attention to the issue – is any reasonable scenario in which Mourdock’s legal challenges would have resulted in a net financial gain to Hoosiers.
See here for detailed analysis, but this is the gist:
The nut of Indiana’s objection is that, under the plan, lesser priority claims will receive value while Indiana’s (and other) first-priority claims will not be made whole. Under a liquidation scenario, typically you sell everything off and then, from that pool of money you pay the first class of creditors (e.g. first priority lien holders). Once they are paid in full, you move on to the second class of creditors (e.g. unsecured lenders). When you reach a class of creditors whose claims exceed the remaining pool of money, you pay those creditors a pro rata share of what’s left. Any remaining classes of creditors get nothing. The important point is that you don’t pay the second class creditors anything until the first class creditors have been paid in full.
Here is the problem with Indiana’s analysis: the restructuring plan under which the government and the UAW and other lesser creditors receive value also provides more money to the first lien creditors than they would get from a liquidation.
Under the scenario that happened, the United States Government was willing to fund payments to Chrysler’s creditors and fund the start up of a new, post-bankruptcy Chrysler, including money that went to unions. That second part pissed off ideologues who don’t like money going to anyone before a privileged group of creditors get paid in full and particularly not to unions. But – and here is the catch – a) the United States Government wasn’t willing to fund the bankruptcy transition under other terms; and b) there were no other buyers willing to pay more for the liquidated assets or otherwise in a manner that would net more to secured creditors than the scenario offered by the government.
To my knowledge, Mourdock has never told us something to the effect of “Hoosiers would have gotten more out of the bankruptcy if the U.S. Government had stayed out, because _______. They would have gotten $0.___ per dollar which is more than the $0.29 per dollar received under the existing decision. This justifies the expenditure of $x million in legal fees.”
The challenger, Pete Buttigieg makes no claim to legal expertise for analyzing the particulars of bankruptcy law, but he notes something that doesn’t often get mentioned – this was junk paper that the State was buying for $0.43 on the dollar:
“One of the facts that he rarely mentions is that when he originally bought Chrysler debt, Chrysler bonds were rated junk bonds,” Buttigieg said. “If we had a safer investment policy to begin with, none of this would have happened.”