Kudos to the Journal & Courier editorial staff. They went ahead and printed the opinion column of Purdue economist, David Hummels which pretty well eviscerated the Journal & Courier’s recent, history-challenged editorial on the “debt crisis.”
Hummels notes that the current political wrangling over spending threatens to be a crisis, not because of the debt or deficit itself, but because of the arbitrary threat to default on payments which would, in a stroke, crush the trust of the financial markets in Treasury Bills as “the mattress investors tuck their money into when uncertainty reigns.” Once that confidence is gone, managing the rest of our financial affairs becomes a lot more difficult.
Secondly, he reminds us that, not so long ago, we had surpluses, not deficits. What changed most dramatically was not spending but revenues.
But the single largest reason for the reversal in budgetary fortunes was the Bush tax cuts.
In 2000 the federal government collected 20.6 percent of GDP in revenue, but only 14.9 percent in 2010. Had tax revenues remained at 2000 levels, we would have run surpluses for all of the last decade except the recession years, and closed two-thirds of the current deficit.
This was well-understood at the time these tax cuts were enacted. They were made subject to “sunset” provisions precisely because every estimate showed that they would bust the budget over time.
Indeed, the baseline forecast of the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office showed that with tax cuts allowed to sunset, U.S. debt and interest payments stabilize at slightly above current levels.
He gently mocks the Journal & Courier’s invocation of World War II patriotism in buying savings bonds while failing to note the taxes paid by The Greatest Generation.
The J&C editorial also noted the patriotism of the World War II generation in buying savings bonds to finance the war effort. It doesn’t mention that taxes paid by the greatest generation tripled during their war years. Perhaps they too grumbled about excessive government spending and tax rates choking off economic growth.
Or maybe they, like previous and subsequent war generations, stepped up to the plate and paid the taxes necessary for the government to function. In contrast, our generation’s patriotic response to the global war on terror was to take a tax holiday.
The Bush tax cuts were a bad idea then — I recall railing against them at the time — they are a worse idea now. Obama screwed up by making a deal to extend them. Go back to the Clinton tax structure, and the rest of the government financial problems become manageable; particularly if we manage to wind down the existing discretionary wars and somehow manage to avoid jumping into other ones.