Hunter at Daily Kos has a post up about the “let him die” moment in the last Republican Presidential debate. Wolf Blitzer posed the question to Ron Paul of an apparently healthy thirty year old who decides not to buy insurance because he thinks he’s healthy; but then something unexpected happens and he requires expensive medical treatment. What should happen to that guy? Rep. Paul responded that a guy should be able to choose their own risks. Blitzer pushed just a bit further, “should we let him die?” The obvious, though unpleasant answer to that — following Rep. Paul’s logic to its conclusion, is yes. Paul hedged on saying, “yes.” But, members of the audience shouted out the answer for him; perhaps with undue enthusiasm.
Hunter’s post mentions that a real life version of this seems to have played out with a former campaign manager of Rep. Paul who died, leaving behind $400,000 in medical bills. Hunter notes that this is not something that can be paid with bake sales and through voluntary charities. He further notes that the people in the crowd yelling to let the hypothetical man die must be aware of this. He says of such people:
It never ceases to amaze me, the emotions that we will wrap up in a flag and call patriotic if it suits us. A large swath of America is made up of very cruel people, people who value their own self-indulgence over the welfare of their neighbors, and they seem uniformly to be the most pompous in their exhortations of both patriotism and godliness. They are here to defend the nation from monsters who would parcel out a modicum of support to all citizens, and not just ones they personally know of or approve of: If they help their fellow man, they want to see the person grovel for it a bit, and helping an anonymous soul is deemed not just a pointless exercise but an insult to their very freedom.
That’s where I disagree with Hunter. I think these people are wrong; but they aren’t cruel; at least not knowingly so. He gets at this a little when he reference the people they “personally know of or approve of.” There are very few actual monsters among us. But, there are plenty of people for whom strangers are little more than an abstraction. And that’s why no sense of empathy stirs them to be concerned about whether the unknown person lives or dies. When confronted with dissonance between their stated logic and the plight of someone they know and care about, there will be some justification about why the person they know is entitled to assistance. But, I suspect social proximity is the determining factor.
As for the “let them die” advocates – and I’m not one of them; I think it does bear mentioning that, until we do let them die, the market is not going to be an effective tool in allocating resources for medical treatment.
Update Following up on this post, Tipsy has some excellent questions of his own.