Are people worthless? It occurred to me that this is the underlying assumption in many ways when we regard public expenditures as sunk costs for which we don’t recognize getting anything of value in return. That’s the primary way in which cuts to those expenditures can be viewed as, essentially, a purely good thing. After all, if we killed everyone off, taxes and government would go away entirely. Nirvana!
I’m not sure how closely related the cause of the firing neuron is to the idea that came to mind, but here is the article that triggered my thought. It was a column about the economics of health care. Particularly this passage:
If we actually prevent diseases or conditions, would our bills go up in the end? People would live longer and develop lots of other chronic diseases that can be expensive to control or treat. And they would draw Social Security.
In the fiscal sense, health improvement can cost us money. But that totally ignores the value to society.
For example, H.I.V. prior to antiretroviral therapy was like a death sentence. With the introduction of those drugs, we took a killer and made it more like a chronic illness. There was a lot of hand-wringing about how do we pay for the drugs. But that completely ignores the value to society.
We think of health care as an expense, but we really should be thinking of health care as an investment. We want to invest where we have the greatest return. I would put prevention in that bucket.
In some fashion, which I have not entirely pinned down yet, I think this also ties into the world view where the biologically human life is of critical importance before birth and after brain death but where the biographical human life in between those points is a matter of relative indifference.