Because it’s never too early to start thinking about the next election, I thought I’d check out the List of Presidents of the United States and just see what the history was in terms of incumbent party versus challenging party after a two term President. I skipped the beginning Presidents because things were so much different during the time of the Federalists and Democratic-Republicans. So, we’ll start with Andy Jackson and go from there:
- Jackson succeeded by same party – Martin Van Buren (1 term).
- Lincoln/Johnson succeeded by same party – Ulysses Grant (2 terms)*
- Grant succeeded by same party – Rutherford B. Hayes (1 term)
- McKinley succeeded by same party – Teddy Roosevelt (2 terms)*
- Roosevelt succeeded by same party – William Howard Taft (1 term)
- Woodrow Wilson succeeded by opposing party – Harding/Coolidge (2 terms).
- Harding/Coolidge succeeded by same party – Herbert Hoover (1 term)*
- Franklin Roosevelt succeeded by same party – Harry Truman (2 terms)*
- Harry Truman succeeded by opposing party – Dwight Eisenhower (2 terms)
- Eisenhower succeeded by opposing party – JFK/Johnson (2 terms)*
- Nixon/Ford succeeded by opposing party – Carter (1 term)
- Ronald Reagan succeeded by same party – George H.W. Bush (1 term)
- Bill Clinton succeeded by opposing party – George W. Bush (2 terms)
- George W. Bush succeeded by opposing party – Barack Obama (2 terms)
*I clearly had some trouble figuring out how to organize those cases where an incumbent won re-election but the vice-president filled some of the first or second term.
No terribly clear patterns, but I guess it looks like in modern times, it’s been less likely for the two term President’s party to win the following election, and almost impossible to win the next two elections.