I stumbled across an article from a couple of years ago by Neal Stephenson from a couple of years ago entitled Innovation Starvation. (Seems like I read it a while back as well; I’m not sure if I commented on it.) He generally laments the seeming inability of our present culture to execute on the big things, as opposed to, say, the America of the early and mid 20th century where we created the airplane, the automobile, nuclear energy, and the computer; not to mention getting people to the moon. He quotes one grizzled NASA veteran as saying, ” A grizzled NASA veteran once told me that the Apollo moon landings were communism’s greatest achievement.”
Stephenson sees a role for science fiction in setting a coherent narrative that will inspire inventors and engineers. He sees current sci-fi as more involved in creating dystopian narratives about the downsides of the technology we currently have.
While I agree that new and coherent narratives facilitate invention; on executing the big stuff, I think our bigger obstacle is probably individualism. Individualism is a good and useful concern; but I don’t think it’s an accident that some of the big accomplishments Stephenson cites, e.g. nuclear energy, computers and rockets, came out of World War II. An existential struggle between nations has a way of bulldozing through a lot of individual or factional disagreements about whether and how to get things done. Not that I’m recommending war – you don’t ask for the mushroom cloud just so you can have a silver lining.