Dave Bangert, writing for the Lafayette Journal & Courier has a good column entitled An ISTEP rebellion brewing? West Lafayette superintendent contends it’s just a matter of time.
He talks about West Lafayette School Corporation superintendent, Rocky Killion’s criticism of ISTEP testing at a program the other day. We spend a ton of money on ISTEP and don’t get much bang for our buck.
Can you imagine, he asked, what could be done if the state poured testing money into a program along the lines of Read to Succeed?
Can you imagine, he asked, going with an easier way to figure out whether a kid can read by third grade: “How about we ask the teacher?”
But, of course, there is money and political capital to be made by distrusting teachers. Marketing requires that you identify a problem of which the consumers were unaware and sell them a solution. So, the schools are failing – let us sell you some testing and private schools
My school is good, and my kid is doing fine. And, yet, my school and my kid had to waste time on these tests. Furthermore, as a champion test taker, I can tell you that standardized tests aren’t great at capturing what kids need to succeed. I was good at those kind of tests, but I was fundamentally lazy. My sisters were far better at excelling in the day-to-day grind of the class room. I never got the 4.0s they got, but I crushed the tests. Thing is, life is a day-to-day grind. The skills you need to excel in a classroom are far more valuable than those you need for test taking. Now that I’m out of school, about all those testing skills do for me is make me kind of a trash talker when I’m playing bar trivia at BW-3.
Meanwhile, my kid has to waste a good chunk of several school days taking (and an unknown amount of time preparing for) a test that tells me what I already know — he’s pretty sharp and he’s learning a lot in school. I suspect other parents and teachers have a pretty good idea of where their kids stand educationally as well.
But, trusting teachers to tell us the truth is unappealing and there is money to be made by mistrusting them, so we’ll continue to spend our resources on a bunch of tests instead of on education.